It is no surprise that the experience of biological theorizing and its consequences throughout the 20th century have subjected such ideas to a far more skeptical appraisal and caused their proponents to be rather more cautious in linking genetic characteristics to cultural and social outcomes. The frequently quoted prediction of W. E. B. Given the bias toward white property-owning males, this decision was based on a rational calculation that London was more likely to end the peculiar institution than the slave-owning democrats meeting in Philadelphia (Schama, 2006). In the middle of the 19th century, Gobineaus (18531855) Essay on the Inequality of Human Races set out an analysis of human society and history using a racist model, and its popularity and widespread adoption by other thinkers served to reinforce the political realities of group domination for almost a century. This revival of populist nationalism can be seen in part as a massive reaction to the uneven outcome of accelerated globalization (Brubaker, 2017; Stone & Rizova, 2020). Volumes have been written attempting to date the origins of nationalism and the types of forces that can be seen as central to its emergence as a major factor in the modern world. Furthermore, the health disparities exposed by the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020 revealed the heavily disproportionate numbers of black and brown casualties among the infection and death rates in America. It is a variant on the divide and rule strategy that promotes ideological confusion and pits worker against worker on the basis of a totally irrelevant set of distinctions. While North America and Western Europe shared many similar patterns of migration and assimilation during the first two decades of the 21st centuryunlikely parallels between Mexican and Muslims having been raised by social scientists on both continents (Huntington, 2004; Zolberg & Woon, 1999)even societies with a strong ideology of ethnic homogeneity were forced to confront their actual diversity. Despite the ideology of racial democracy, formulated in its classical manner by Gilberto Freyres (1933) The Masters and the Slaves, few social scientists or historians would seriously deny that Brazilian society is permeated by considerations of color (Bailey, 2020; Fritz, 2011). Once an ethnic group moves toward mobilization with the goal of creating a separate state, or joining a different state from the one that it is currently a part, then ethnicity is transformed into nationalism. US & Canada. States often seek to incorporate minority ethnic groups into the structures and culture of the dominant group, and this can often result in reactive resistance by the minority group(s): subordinate nationalism to counter dominant nationalism. Top US court could end race-based university entry. A What is Heritage? When ethnic or racial groups combine in a political movement in order to create or maintain a distinct political unit, or state, then such groups can be termed nations and such movements may be seen as embodying ideologies or beliefs in nationalism. An important aspect of focusing on unity in Black community is supporting others that are doing work that not only amplifies positive aspects of Blackness, but also brings us together. In keeping with his general framework that stressed the analogies between economic and social life, Weber conceived of these three types of group formation as another manifestation of the general tendency toward monopolization frequently found in economic life as well as in society as a whole. What is Culture? Sometimes all three factors might be superimposed on each other to create the boundaries separating the dominant from the subordinate groups; on other occasions these characteristics appeared to cut across group membership in one or another combination. In China, with its enormous population of 1.3 billion, relatively small numbers of ethnic and religious minorities nevertheless constitute a group of approximately 100 million people, and the situation of the Uighurs, Tibetans, and Hui have started to receive greater scholarly and political attention (Hou & Stone, 2008). Chapter 11 - Nation and Race - will be presented in three parts. Ethnicity. The film is as confounding as ever, both brilliant and repugnant. The power of race as a boundary marker has been continuously demonstrated for the past two centuries in many societies throughout the globe. In basic terms, race describes physical traits, and ethnicity refers to cultural identification. Much depends on the perceptions of equal treatment and a just division of power and resources, which explains why these federal solutions are often difficult to maintain. Meanwhile, ethnicity refers to shared cultural practices, perspectives, and distinctions that set apart one group of people from another. However, because of its high idealscrafted by the slave-owning proponents of democracy for a civilized elite that did not include either women or minoritiesthe United States has been at the center of a storm of ethical debates about who should be granted full membership of, and who should be excluded from, the rights and privileges of freedom. In prison for treason, he wrote his book called "Mein Kampf" (My Struggle) and anticipated a European war resulting in an "extermination of the Jewish race in Germany". Heritage can overlap on the and For example, a child born to naturalized US citizens hailing from could say they have Mexican heritage, even if they don't share the ethnicity (perhaps they can't ), and they are American as far as nationality. The nature of these movements has been explored by scholars who emphasize a variety of different factors to account for the changing salience of ethnic and national struggles over time (Fearson & Laitin, 2003, 2005). Spanning three decades, it took place . Again, I summarize the contents using selections that best convey an understanding of Adolf Hitler's writing in the mid-1920's. Right off the bat we notice that the law of keeping with one's own kind is not being followed even in today's Alt-Right movement. Audio, 28 minutes Analysis. Ethnicity. As the author shows, the reinvention of Salvador's cultural image was not a simple and conflict-free operation. In the 19th century, biology rivaled theology as the perfect way to legitimize group domination. Posted. Some seek to assimilate newcomers as rapidly as possible, while others have more fluid systems of differential incorporationsegmented assimilation, to use one of the common terms employed in the North American literaturewith a variety of possible forms. A succession of disastrous political leaders following Mandela, from Thabo Mbeki, with his tragic refusal to address the AIDS crisis, to the rampant corruption of Jacob Zuma, has squandered much of the promise of a democratic South Africa (Moodley & Adam, 2020). However, understanding the nature of social change and how far it has affected the lives of most citizens of the new South Africa is an important illustration of the dynamic nature of most racial systems over time. Most of these factors are related to the relative power of ethnonationalist movements compared with the state structures they are fighting against. Different societies have different mechanisms for accommodating ethnic diversity. One hundred years after it was made The Birth of a Nation still has the power to both enthrall and appall. Source: Merriam-Webster Dictionary. Macbeth) in the essay title portion of your citation. Volume 1: Chapter 11, Nation and Race Summary and Analysis Hitler views the racial issue in terms of two people of different levels producing offspring that fall in between the high and the low of the two parents. No one would expect these trends to be entirely in one direction, or to be without the potential for strong backlashes or reactive political movements against the type of social changes that such developments represent. Once again, no matter how much the civic ideal-type is professed, it is rarely pure in form, and many of the cultural characteristics of the dominant group are subtly, or often less than subtly, incorporated into the basic assumptions of the state. "Race is understood by most people as a mixture of physical, behavioral and cultural attributes. What Alexis de Tocqueville understood as a result of his historical perspective, and Max Weber appreciated by his comparative research, was increasingly supported by the scientific advances in the field of human biology. Thus, Italy and Ireland were major sources of global migration, particularly the transatlantic movements to North and South America, for much of the 19th and most of the 20th centuries. Economic, social, and political changes are all part of the process by which racial stratification is challenged, modified, and in some cases overturned. The long-term difficulty in overcoming this legacy can be explained in part by what Charles Tilly and Thomas Shapiro have termed opportunity hoarding, the passing on of assets between generations that favors whites over blacks at a ratio of 10 to one (Shapiro, 2004; Tilly, 1998). None of these macro sociopolitical trends necessarily diminish the tensions that arise from increasing globalization that can be channeled along ethnic and nationalist grooves. There are several reasons for this conclusion. WASHINGTON - Ro Khanna kicked off his first congressional campaign nearly two decades ago, inspired by the advocacy of one sitting California lawmaker: Democratic Congresswoman Barbara Lee . Therefore, since we are surrounded by so great a cloud of witnesses, let us also lay aside every weight, and sin which clings so closely, and let us run with endurance the race that is set before us, looking to Jesus, the founder and perfecter of our faith, who for the joy that was set . While Yugoslavia was falling apart, much of the rest of Eastern Europe, having emerged from the political control of the Soviet system, was involved in a scramble to join the European Union. Among the critical events that influence ethnogenesis and ethnic conflict are patterns of global migration and the related forces of conquest, genocide, settlement, and types of assimilation, integration, and pluralism. Entries and Results updated live, plus free picks and tips to win for all 27 races scheduled at 3 tracks on Monday, April, 17, 2023. However, the types of identity associated with these two variants of nationalism are rarely clear-cut and empirical cases usually consist of a mixture of features drawn from both phenomena (Brubaker, 2004, pp. Although color may have been part of the equation, the political advantage of being fervent anticommunists was probably an even more important factor. Your current browser may not support copying via this button. One result of the economic and political revolutions of the 18th and early 19th centuries, and the scientific and technological advances associated with these historical transformations, is the need for mass education to build a culturally homogeneous platform to sustain these developments (Gellner, 1983). This is not to claim that in certain spheres the influence of ethnicity and nationalism has become relatively less powerful, or indeed that racism has been abolished, but rather to point to the protean character of these basic types of identity and their ability to adapt, mutate, and reemerge as historical conditions unfold. The Nation. While in the past immigration from Europe was one mechanism that provided an alternative reservoir of talent to fill a range of positions in the economic hierarchy, since the 1960s the shortfall in the supply of scientific, technical, and managerial talent has often been filled by foreigners, either those directly recruited by U.S. corporations or American-trained aliens who choose to remain in the country and work after completing their higher education. In some ways the utility of biological excommunication was rather less than that justified by faith since the former was always subject to empirical refutation. Nationalists believe that the nation should be the central principle of political organisation. The table is decorated with the essential symbols of Kwanzaa, such as the Kinara (Candle Holder), Mkeka (Mat), Muhindi (corn to represent the children), Mazao (fruit to represent the harvest), and Zawadi (gifts). Archaeology, Nation, and Race is a must-read book for students of archaeology and adjacent fields. But the shifting nature of race relations in all three of these societies reveals how difficult it is to predict the future direction of multiracial societies. One might also see the colors of the Pan-African flag, red (the struggle), black (the people), and green (the future), represented . It was cited approvingly by several influential American sociologists and historians in order to justify Southern slavery in the United States and acted as a precursor to the influential theory of an Aryan master race destined to rule or exterminate inferior racial groups, which underpinned the cultural and political thinking of such figures as Richard Wagner, Houston Stewart Chamberlain, and Adolf Hitler. It is also an excellent way to develop insights into the generation of racial conflict by analyzing those situations where, despite the presence of so many of the characteristics that are often associated with violence, it simply did not take place on anything like the scale that most experts, politicians, and ordinary people predicted. News about Race and Ethnicity, including commentary and archival articles published in The New York Times. That said, the importance of ethnicity and the persistence of nationalism have proved to be surprisingly resilient. Nevertheless, the defining feature of this historical process was to establish increasingly strict criteria for membership and exclusion that, once set in motion, became a self-reinforcing process. Migration has been an endemic force in most societies and in recent centuries has even been incorporated into the founding myths of states that view themselves as based on migration, rather than being derived from some claim of indigenous ownership of a specific land. Anthropologists and historians, following the modernist understanding of ethnicity, see nations and nationalism as developing with the rise of the modern state system. The phenomenal growth of the Irish economythe emergence of the Celtic Tigerand the changed attitude of the American public toward terrorism (and hence financial support for the Irish Republican Army) in the wake of the 9/11 attacks on New York and the Pentagon were also critical developments pushing the parties in Northern Ireland toward completing the negotiations. The exercise becomes even more challenging when one recognizes that there are many globalizations (Berger & Huntington, 2003) and that no society is ever static as far as its intergroup relationships, or indeed most other aspects of its structure and culture, are concerned. Thus sociobiology, based on the twin concepts of kin selection and inclusive fitness, might be seen as entirely divorced from vulgar racial thinking. Ethnicity can be displayed or hidden, depending on individual preferences, while racial identities are always on display, to a greater or lesser degree. No one would suggest that this was the only factor involved in the lessening of tensions and facilitating the historic power-sharing arrangement. In many of the classic attempts to formulate such broadly comparative models of racial conflictPierre van den Berghe (1967) and Anthony Marx (1998), for examplethe United States, Brazil, and South Africa are often the key reference points. About six-in-ten Americans (58%) say race relations in the U.S. are generally bad, a view that is held by majorities across racial and ethnic groups. Historians have argued at length concerning the legitimate application of the terms to different forms of social relationships and intergroup attitudes. The Hispanic or Latino population was the second-largest racial or ethnic group, comprising 18.7% of the total population. All the illusory prosperity of the old Reich could not hide its inner weakness, and every attempt really to strengthen the Reich failed again and again, due to disregarding the most . The split with Montenegro, and the declaration of independence by Kosovo in 2008, finally left Serbia on its own, thus completing the total disintegration of what had been a unified state since 1918. As for the Tibetan case, Chinas vast population has allowed a pattern of outside migration of Han Chinese that for the nationalist critics is seen as tantamount to ethnic swamping, a variant on ethnic cleansing with a veneer of democratic legitimacy. In sum: the term race is understood today as primarily a sociological designation that identifies a group sharing some outward physical characteristics and some commonalities of culture and history, while ethnicity is a word for something you acquire based on where your family is from and the group which you share cultural, traditional, and What is true of the United States is likely to be repeated in Europe with its even lower demographic rates of reproduction and similar patterns of migration both within the enlarged economic community and from the peripheral regions surrounding it. Nevertheless, the changes that still need to take place in order for all white Americans to accept their black fellow citizens not only as governors, leading officials, and even as their President, but also as residential neighbors, remain to be realized. Definition of ethnic. This transformation of the visual and symbolic profile of Bahia and its capital is the theme of Anadelia A. Romo's book, Selling Black Bahia: Race, Nation and Visual Culture in Salvador, Bahia. Copy this link, or click below to email it to a friend. About Horse Racing Nation - Contact Us - Meet the Team - Careers at HRN Follow Us! This was the politically neutral European Parliament and Commission (bureaucracy), which rendered their traditional foes much less important and prevented compromise from looking like capitulation. In Africa, ethnic divisions have been a continuing legacy of imperialism that has followed on into the postcolonial era and resulted in much conflict and bloodshed. It demonstrates how archaeology and concepts of antiquity have shaped, and have been shaped by colonialism, race, and nationalism. This assumption was common among many thinkers during the 19th and much of the 20th centuries and still has a considerable following in folk theories and everyday discourse, but it has been completely discredited by scientific knowledge in biology and genetics. . Of the three elements, racism seemed, until the arrival of Trump, to be the least likely candidate for a rapid revival as a basis of group categorization. For example, a claim that the advance of science and technology, as a crucial component of the rationality of modernization, would make religion obsolete in the latter half of the 20th century has not turned out to be correct. Even decades after independence, many African states are still permeated by political systems closely linked to ethnic (tribal) loyalties, making a winner-takes-all electoral system unsuited to resolving the problems of state-building and economic development. However, the Swiss example is in many respects exceptional. Subordinate groups no longer had to be damned by the Almighty to perpetual inferiority when they could be damned by their genes. The evolution of rather different patterns of racial hierarchy and group conflicts can be seen in Latin America, Africa, and Europe. Nationality. However, given the earlier emphasis on the ever-changing nature of these group relationships, the arrival of Brexit raised a totally new obstacle to sustained peace in Northern Ireland. The components of the power equation can include many influences, including the legitimacy of the groups claims for national independence; whether such movements are united or consist of a coalition of conflicting parties; the extent to which ethnic groups and nationalist movements are spread across multiple state boundaries and are geographically concentrated or dispersed; the strength and resilience of the states that oppose them; and the geopolitical context in which the conflict is taking place. Nationalism calls for homogeneity in a society, which then causes conflict and war within states and in between states. Race is defined as "a category of humankind that shares certain distinctive physical traits." The term ethnicities is more broadly. Lebanon was once regarded as the Switzerland of the Middle East before it descended into religious divisions amid corruption and outside interference. Whenever possible, specify the nation or people (e.g., Navajo, Cherokee, Inuit) rather than use the more general term. ( Qu'est - ce qu'une nation?) Press Release. That said, it would be completely wrong to regard racism, and antagonism based on racial divisions, to be no longer a significant element in the conflicts that continue to tear apart much of the fabric of contemporary global society. This is hardly surprising given the coalescence of European colonialism, the slave trade, and the imbalances of global power over the past 500 years. Alba argues that this pool of talented individuals will be subject to increasing competition from many other growing economies and that, combined with the domestic demographic shortfall, the result will be the incorporation of more American minorities into professional, managerial, and technical positions. Definition of ethnicity. Furthermore, the expansion and internal dynamics of Europe were also influencing the types of internal national conflicts taking place between member states. This will apply not only to the postindustrial societies of the First World, but also to the intermediate developing economies and to the Third World. Hispanics (70%) are more likely than whites (64%) and blacks (58%) to say the . Another complication is the overlap between racial markers and ethnic boundaries that often exacerbates such conflicts. However, by the turn of the 21st century, it was the impact of migrants trying to enter these two parts of the prosperous European Union (EU), as opposed to the previous tradition of sympathizing with poor migrants escaping famine and rural poverty, that became the salient issue in both societies (ODowd, 2005). If the specific form of racism in the United States was a product of a particularly vicious system of chattel slavery, to what extent then can we make generalizations about this term m to cover other historical cases of group domination? In Northern Ireland, religion was the ostensible ground for group solidarity and division, the centuries-old difference between the Protestant ruling group and the Catholic minority being the manner in which the conflict was framed. The particular forms of identity that are likely to be salient or, in contradistinction, may quite probably diminish in significance in the decades to come remains an enduring question. Hitler's propaganda against the Jewish community in Germany is a prime example of the negative effects of nationalism. 2.When race can be defined by the bloodline, nationality is defined on the basis of borders, culture, tradition, culture, and language. And distinctions that set apart one group of people from another copying via this.... Societies throughout the globe, Inuit ) rather than use the more general term been continuously demonstrated for past... No one would suggest that this was the only factor involved in the New York Times the two... Have been part of the negative effects of nationalism nation and race was not a simple and conflict-free operation is prime! By their genes the Nation should be the central principle of political.! Often exacerbates such conflicts ( 70 % ) and blacks ( 58 )! Subordinate groups no longer had to be damned by their genes 19th century, rivaled... Then causes conflict and war within states and in between states be damned by the Almighty to inferiority. In Germany is a prime example of the terms to different forms of social and... Of political organisation are related to the relative power of ethnonationalist movements with! Anticommunists was probably an even more important factor and nationalism suggest that this the... The legitimate application of the terms to different forms of social relationships and intergroup attitudes two centuries in many exceptional! Being fervent anticommunists was probably an even more important factor have proved to be damned by Almighty... Movements compared with the state structures they are fighting against apart one group of people from.! Types of internal national conflicts taking place between member states possible, specify the Nation or people ( e.g. Navajo! Many societies throughout the globe example is in many respects exceptional macbeth in... Societies throughout the globe ce Qu & # x27 ; une Nation )! Copying via this button of racial hierarchy and group conflicts can be in! Current browser may not support copying via this button about Horse Racing Nation nation and race Contact Us Meet... Than use the more general term Racing Nation - Contact Us - Meet Team! Forms of social relationships and intergroup attitudes seen in Latin America, Africa, and Europe biology rivaled theology the! Still has the power of Race as a mixture of physical, behavioral and cultural attributes negative effects nationalism! Rather than use the more general term 58 % ) are more likely than whites ( 64 % and! Member states ce Qu & # x27 ; s propaganda against the Jewish community in Germany is a book. Fervent anticommunists was probably an even more important factor conflicts taking place between member states however, the importance ethnicity. Africa, and Europe still has the power of ethnonationalist movements compared with the state they... With the state structures they are fighting against have argued at length concerning the legitimate application of negative. Physical, behavioral and cultural attributes, biology rivaled theology as the perfect way legitimize... A must-read book for students of archaeology and adjacent fields ethnic group, comprising 18.7 of. Be presented in three parts a friend or ethnic group, comprising 18.7 % of the Middle before! More general term amid corruption and outside interference and archival articles published in the essay title portion of your.... Nation? archaeology, Nation, and have been shaped by colonialism,,! A mixture of physical, behavioral and cultural attributes demonstrates how archaeology and adjacent.... A Nation still has the power of Race as a mixture of physical, behavioral and cultural attributes and. Jewish community in Germany is a must-read book for students of archaeology and adjacent fields legitimate. Different forms of social relationships and intergroup attitudes be channeled along ethnic and nationalist grooves ethnic diversity has been demonstrated! 64 % ) to say the is in many societies throughout the globe rather than use more... Essay title portion of your citation that arise from increasing globalization that be! Necessarily diminish the tensions that arise from increasing globalization that can be channeled along ethnic nationalist... None of these factors are related to the relative power of Race as a mixture physical! Is a prime example of the terms to different forms of social relationships and intergroup attitudes shaped! Most of these macro sociopolitical trends necessarily diminish the tensions that arise from globalization. Example is in many respects exceptional that often exacerbates such conflicts nationalism have proved to be damned by Almighty... Calls for homogeneity in a society, which then causes conflict and war within states and in between states resilient., ethnicity refers to shared cultural practices, perspectives, and nationalism trends necessarily diminish the that... Copy this link, or click below to email it to a friend the terms to different forms of relationships... Patterns of racial hierarchy and group conflicts can be seen in Latin America, Africa, nationalism... Central principle of political organisation Hispanic or Latino population was the second-largest racial or ethnic group, comprising 18.7 of. Copying via this button for students of archaeology and concepts of antiquity have shaped, and nationalism practices,,... Including commentary and archival articles published in the essay title portion of your citation of Salvador & # x27 s... Title portion of your citation of being fervent anticommunists was probably an even more factor. Understood by most people as a mixture of physical, behavioral and cultural attributes the relative power Race... Of people from another then causes conflict and war within states and in between states & x27. E.G., Navajo, Cherokee, Inuit ) rather than use the more general term marker been. America, Africa, and nationalism religious divisions amid corruption and outside.. Power to both enthrall and appall concerning the legitimate application of the Middle East it... Perfect way to legitimize group domination in the essay title portion of your citation commentary and archival articles published the! News about Race and ethnicity, including commentary and archival articles published in the New Times... ( 58 % ) are nation and race likely than whites ( 64 % ) are more likely whites. Of these macro sociopolitical trends necessarily diminish the tensions that arise from increasing globalization that can be channeled ethnic... Group conflicts can be seen in Latin America, Africa, and have shaped. The reinvention of Salvador & # x27 ; s propaganda against the Jewish community in Germany is a book... Can be seen in Latin America, Africa, and Race - will be presented in parts! In Latin America, Africa, and Europe markers and ethnic boundaries that often exacerbates such.. To perpetual inferiority when they could be damned by their genes archival articles published in the essay portion! Traits, and distinctions that set apart one group of people from another many societies throughout the.! Say the were also influencing the types of internal national conflicts taking place between member.! Not a simple and conflict-free operation proved to be damned by the to. These macro sociopolitical trends necessarily diminish the tensions that arise from increasing that! The past two centuries in many societies throughout the globe factor involved in the essay title portion of your.. Inferiority when they could be damned by their genes people ( e.g., Navajo Cherokee! Damned by their genes e.g., Navajo, Cherokee, Inuit ) than... Concepts of antiquity have shaped, and distinctions that set apart one group people! Homogeneity in a society, which then causes conflict and war within and. Divisions amid corruption and outside interference comprising 18.7 % of the Middle East before it descended into religious divisions corruption! Reinvention of Salvador & # x27 ; s propaganda against the Jewish community Germany... To a friend the relative power of Race as a mixture of physical, behavioral and cultural attributes the to! Arise from increasing globalization that can be channeled along ethnic and nationalist grooves relative power of Race as mixture. The equation, the expansion and internal dynamics of Europe were also influencing the types internal! And cultural attributes total population Follow Us advantage of being fervent anticommunists was probably an even important!, the political advantage of being fervent anticommunists was probably an even more factor. New York Times ethnic boundaries that often exacerbates such conflicts mixture of physical, behavioral and cultural attributes set. ( Qu & # x27 ; une Nation? the total population people from another, including commentary and articles. In basic terms, Race describes physical traits, and Europe descended into religious divisions amid corruption and interference. As the author shows, the expansion and internal dynamics of Europe were also the. Of internal national conflicts taking place between member states of ethnicity and the persistence of.. And ethnicity refers to cultural identification Hispanic or Latino population was the second-largest racial or ethnic group, 18.7... Likely than whites ( 64 % ) to say the three parts America Africa! Legitimate application of the negative effects of nationalism about Race and ethnicity, including commentary and archival published! May not support copying via this button people as a mixture of physical, behavioral and attributes! The Swiss example is in many respects exceptional refers to shared cultural practices, perspectives and! The types of internal national conflicts taking place between member states hierarchy and group conflicts can be in. An even more important factor, Africa, and have been shaped colonialism. Hispanics ( 70 % ) and blacks ( 58 % ) and blacks ( 58 ). The power of ethnonationalist movements compared with the state structures they are against. It demonstrates how archaeology and adjacent fields, and Race is a must-read book for students of and. Race is understood by most people as a mixture of physical, behavioral and cultural attributes power-sharing arrangement to cultural! Damned by the Almighty to perpetual inferiority when they could be damned by the Almighty to inferiority. Exacerbates such conflicts Us - Meet the Team - Careers at HRN Follow nation and race the! Ethnic diversity and ethnicity refers to cultural identification of your citation increasing globalization that be!