Americans were on edge awaiting the verdict, which was read in court by Hennepin County Judge Peter Cahill. Fox News Flash top headlines are here. Nearly a year later, in April 2021, a jury convicted Chauvin of second-degree murder, third-degree murder and second-degree manslaughter. He said, "You . or redistributed. Eight of the jurors identify as white, four as Black and two as mixed race. SEE ALSO: George Floyd's family calls verdict in Derek Chauvin trial a victory: 'We won'. Janelle Griffith is a national reporter for NBC News focusing on issues of race and policing. He also teamed up with Earl Gray, an attorney representing one of the other ex-officers charged in connection with Floyds death, to defend another homicide suspect, according to Halberg. MINNEAPOLIS The Minnesota Court of Appeals on Monday upheld former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin's second-degree murder conviction in the killing of George Floyd, and let his 22. In what he has since described as "a moment of insanity," Betts, then a 16-year . Defense attorney Eric Nelson (left) with his client, former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin, on Monday. You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times. ", He reminded jurors that proof beyond a reasonable doubt, according to the definition read earlier by the judge, was such proof as ordinary, prudent men and women would act upon in their most important affairs.. Over the past three weeks of jury selection, Mr. Nelson appeared in court each day with Mr. Chauvin and an assistant, Amy Voss. Activists say it would teach police urban warfare and destroy public forests. Chauvin faces decades in prison and is expected to be sentenced in about two months. Appellate courts give judges wide discretion and are loath to micromanage how they run trials, he said. Upstate NY woman, 20, fatally shot after turning down wrong driveway, They spent their lives teaching Californias children. Fox News Flash top headlines for March 27. All rights reserved. Former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin's defense attorney introduced a new element to the trial on Wednesday, by suggesting that George Floyd said the words "I ate too many drugs". He likened Nelsons resolve to a scene from the movie "Hoosiers," in which Gene Hackmans character brings his small-town basketball team to an intimidating bigtime venue for their state championship game and measures the net to show them the basket is the same height. Stephanie Pagones is a Digital Reporter for FOX Business and Fox News. But the appeals court ruled that Cahill did not abuse his discretion in deciding those issues. Atlanta officials say a new training center would reimagine policing. Harriette Cole: How do I tell him we'll never be housemates? Derek Chauvin, the former Minneapolis police officer charged in the killing of George Floyd, is being represented by Eric Nelson, an attorney who's exclusively practiced criminal defense. It was a conclusion drawn by several legal experts who provided observations about the performances of the prosecution and the defense, both of which have rested their cases after nearly three weeks of witness testimony in the closely watched trial. The law only permits police officers to use reasonable force when effecting a lawful arrest. However, no one is above the law, Appeals Judge Peter Reyes wrote for the panel. Legal Statement. He was sentenced on Friday, June 25. ", Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison, who assembled the prosecution team, said in a statement that he was "grateful we have a system where everyone, no matter how egregious their offense, is entitled to due process and fair treatment.". The defense said a 2021 Minnesota Supreme Court decision in a different police killing case that clarified the definition of that crime meant the law no longer fit the facts of Floyd's killing. MINNEAPOLIS The Minnesota Court of Appeals on Monday upheld former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin's second-degree murder conviction in the killing of George Floyd, and let his 22 1/2-year sentence remain in place. Floyd died May 25, 2020, after Chauvin, who is white, used his knee to pin the Black mans neck to the ground for 9 minutes. Defense attorney Eric Nelson, left, and former Minneapolis police Officer Derek Chauvin at the Hennepin County Courthouse in Minneapolis on March 30. Fox News' Matt Finn and Ruth Ravve and The Associated Press contributed to this report. Appellate courts give judges wide discretion and are loath to micromanage how they run trials, he said. "We have an old saying, We don't build them. On the other hand, Chauvin's defense attorney, Nelson, asked Stoughton on cross examination, under which requirements he performed a use-of-force analysis in the case. "We saw in that case that race trumped gender. Schultz said he believes the prosecution should count as a win the testimony of multiple medical experts, such as Tobin, a lung and critical care specialist at the Edward Hines Jr. VA Hospital and Loyola University's medical school in Illinois. Mr. Chauvins defense is paid through the legal defense fund of the Minnesota Police and Peace Officers Association. Nelson presented his closing remarks in the case on Monday, April 19. The appeals court declined to address whether it was legally permissible to convict Chauvin of third-degree murder. Local defense attorney Mike Brandt, who has followed the case closely, said he was not surprised that the appeals court affirmed . Who is Derek Chauvins defense attorney Eric Nelson? Check out what's clicking on Foxnews.com. Legal Statement. He and his family live in Minneapolis. All Access Digital offer for just 99 cents! Turn on desktop notifications for breaking stories about interest? Chauvin's attorney had asked the appeals court to throw out the ex-officer's convictions for a long list of . Who is Derek Chauvin's defense attorney Eric Nelson? Powered by. . In April 1993, two of the four officers were convicted. Floyd family attorney Ben Crump called it thelargest pretrial settlementever for a civil rights claim. Nelson is admitted to practice law in Minnesota and Wisconsin state courts, in the U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota and in the Western and Eastern Districts of Wisconsin federal court. On Monday, 10 months after George Floyd's death, the trial . But Neal Katyal, a special attorney for the state, argued that Chauvin got one of the most transparent and thorough trials in our nations history.". Meanwhile, Eric D. Anderson, whose legal career includes more than 150 jury and bench trials in state and federal courts, told Fox News he had not expected Chauvin to be acquitted across the board, but thought it might be possible that the trial would end in a hung jury. "At this time due to some additional legal matters at hand I'm not able to give a full statement at this time, but very briefly though I want to send my condolences to theFloydfamily,"Chauvinsaid. He also has been able to turn to the eight other attorneys in the MPPOAs 12-lawyer rotation, the AP reported. Floyd, a 46-year-old Black man,died May 25, 2020, after being arrested on suspicion of passing a counterfeit $20 bill for a pack of cigarettes at a corner market. He said the publicity and the riots, the city's $27 million settlement with Floyd's family announced during jury selection, the unrest over a police killing of a Black man in a Minneapolis suburb during jury selection, and the sealing off of the courthouse, were just some of the factors prejudicing Chauvin's chance of a fair trial. Local defense attorney Mike Brandt, who has followed the case closely, said he was not surprised that the appeals court affirmed Chauvins conviction and found no errors that would have changed the outcome. Chauvin Attorney Fears Impact of $27 Million Settlement With Floyd's Family, An attorney for the former Minneapolis police officer charged in George Floyd's death said Monday that he's "gravely concerned" that the announcement of a $27 million settlement for Floyd's family makes it impossible for his client to get a fair trial. The ex-officer is accused of murder in the May 2020 death of George Floyd. Jun 25, 2021, 4:43 PM Insider Derek Chauvin was sentenced to 22 1/2 years in prison for the murder of George Floyd. What the defense is going to want to do is confuse the jurors, Schultz and Osler said. MINNEAPOLIS -- The Minnesota Court of Appeals on Monday upheld former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin's second-degree murder conviction in the killing of George Floyd, and let his 22 1/2-year sentence remain in place, AP reported. One expert called the conviction a "preordained conclusion.". The more technical and specialized testimony of medical experts and police was balanced with that of everyday people who had been going about their day when they happened upon Floyd and Chauvin. Closing arguments are set to begin Monday. Derek Chauvin verdict: Guilty on all charges in death of George Floyd. "He's not terrible," Kavanagh said of Nelson. A jury had found Chauvin, 45, guilty of second degree murder, third degree murder, and manslaughter. "Resting comfortably on the pavement?" Police officers undoubtedly have a challenging, difficult, and sometimes dangerous job. In all, Osler said, the prosecution was far more effective not because of the lawyers, but because of their witnesses, specifically, Minneapolis police Chief Medaria Arradondo and Dr. Martin Tobin, a world-renowned pulmonologist. The Courts decision today shows once again no one is above the law and no one is beneath it, Ellison said. or redistributed. He said the publicity and the riots, the citys $27-million settlement with Floyds family announced during jury selection, the unrest over a police killing of a Black man in a Minneapolis suburb during jury selection, and the sealing off of the courthouse, were just some of the factors prejudicing Chauvins chance of a fair trial. It happens when a person carries out a dangerous action, which they knew had the potential to kill, but disregards the risk. 0:57. Market data provided by Factset. "The primary issue on this appeal is whether a criminal defendant can get a fair trial consistent with constitutional requirements in a courthouse surrounded by concrete block, barbed wire, two armored personnel carriers, and a squad of National Guard troops, all of which or whom are there for one purpose: in the event that the jury acquits the defendant," Mohrman said in oral arguments in January. Defense attorney Eric Nelson gave his opening statement during Derek Chauvin's trial for the murder of George Floyd on March 29, 2021. Derek Chauvin's defense attorney began his closing argument Monday by reminding jurors that his client is presumed innocent of the charges he faces over the death of George Floyd and that. Multiple bystanders cried on the stand. Chauvin's attorney had asked the appeals court to throw out the ex-officer's convictions for a long list of reasons, including the massive pretrial publicity. He could face decades in prison (sentencing was expected . Story tips can be sent to stephanie.pagones@fox.com and on Twitter: @steph_pagones. "The evidence of Chauvin's guilt was captured on video for the world to see.". By Glenn Kirschner, former assistant U.S. attorney for the District of Columbia and NBC/MSNBC legal analyst. Michael Brandt, another Minnesota attorney, told The Post, Sometimes you dont see him coming. In an email to Fox News, she added: "This verdict clearly establishes that the jury believed that Chauvins egregious actions on that day were more than negligent, more than a depraved mind, but a deliberate and intentional decision on the part of Derek Chauvin to cause injury to George Floyd, thereby causing his death.". And the viral video that shook this nation and others spurring protests, calls for racial justice and demands for police reform has been played for jurors, in full or in part, nearly every day. Dr. Andrew Baker, the Hennepin County medical examiner who performed an autopsy on Floyd and declared his death a homicide, testified that fentanyl and heart disease had contributed to Floyd's death but that the police officers' actions were the main cause. He eventually conceded that Chauvin's knee on Floyd's neck likely caused Floyd pain and therefore could be considered force. The Minnesota Court of Appeals on Monday upheld former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvins second-degree murder conviction in the killing of George Floyd, and let his 22 1/2-year sentence remain in place. According to The Washington Post, Nelson represented Levi Acre-Kendall in 2015, successfully arguing self defense in a fatal stabbing. CHAUVIN TRIAL: MINNESOTA SUPREME COURT REJECTS APPEAL OVER 3RD-DEGREE MURDER CHARGE REINSTATEMENT. Speaker 1: ( 00:00) This is Eric Nelson- Eric Nelson: ( 00:01) Black Teenager Shot in Kansas City, Missouri. Who is Derek Chauvins mom Carolyn Pawlenty? Cheers and honking car horns could be heard outside the Hennepin County Courthouse after the verdict was read. Mr. Nelson, 46, took charge of the former police officer Derek Chauvins defense over the summer, after his first lawyer retired. Hennepin County Judge Peter Cahill sentenced Chauvin to 22 1/2 years after jurors found him guilty of second-degree murder, third-degree murder and second-degree manslaughter. He continued: "That is what you, as jurors, are obligated to do. The landmark case has riveted a nation wrestling with the issues of police brutality and racial injustice it raised. He has previously been named a Top 40 Under 40 by the National Trial Lawyers and a Top Ten Trial Attorney by the National Academy of Criminal Defense Attorneys. His appeal also focused on one juror who participated in a civil rights event commemorating the Rev. IE 11 is not supported. Before taking on Mr. Chauvins case, Mr. Nelsons most famous client was Amy Senser, the wife of the former Minnesota Vikings tight end Joe Senser. The three people on the defense side of the courtroom are a sharp contrast to the multiple lawyers who have so far appeared for the prosecution, including Minnesotas attorney general, Keith Ellison, and several high-powered outside lawyers who are working pro bono for the state, including Neal Katyal, a lawyer from Washington, D.C., and the former acting solicitor general during the Obama administration. 2020 THE SUN, US, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED | TERMS OF USE | PRIVACY | YOUR AD CHOICES | SITEMAP, Eric Nelson speaks as Hennepin County Judge PeterCahill presides during opening statements, Monday, March 29, 2021, in the trial of former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin, Eric Nelson is a founding partner at Halberg Defense, George FLoyd with his daughter in a court handout photo Credit:HENNEPIN COUNTY COURTHOUSE, That neck restraint, prosecutors argued, was the direct cause of Floyd's death and laid out evidence that he died from low levels of oxygen Credit:REX, Authorities across the US have been bracing for protests in anticipation of the trial's outcome Credit:GETTY, People demonstrate outside the Hennepin County Government Center during the first day of the trial of former police Derek Chauvin, Who is Eric Nelson? Third-degree murder is defined by "by perpetrating an act eminently dangerous to others and evincing a depraved mind," without regard for life and without intent to kill. According to his firms website, Nelson has experience as a defense attorney in cases of homicide, sex offenses, drug offenses, assaults and hundreds of DWI and alcohol-related traffic offenses. Nelson is an expert on driving while intoxicated cases and contributes to the Minnesota DWI Deskbook for attorneys, according to his biography on the firms website. The evidence of Chauvins guilt was captured on video for the world to see.. Chauvin, who is White, appeared on video for roughly nine minutes pressing his knee into the neck of Floyd, a Black man, during an arrest video of which went viral and prompted nationwide protests. In that capacity he has successfully represented numerous members of the LDF in critical incidents and job-related investigations., Peters told The AP, I saw a couple of reports of, The MPPOA selected a DWI lawyer to represent Chauvin. A bystander video captured Floyd's fading cries of "I can't breathe." So he is a perfect fit for a case of this level of pressure.". Nelson will be the only lawyer sitting alongside Chauvin in court during the trial, while the prosecution team will have 14 attorneys, many of whom will be rotating into the court for different portions of the proceedings. Local defense attorney Mike Brandt, who has followed the case closely, said he was not surprised that the appeals court affirmed Chauvin's conviction and found no errors that would have changed . Legal Statement. When they commit a crime, they must be held accountable just as those individuals that they lawfully apprehend. We just fly them,'" Anderson said. Darnella Frazier, who was 17 when she recorded the now-viral video and uploaded it to Facebook, gave emotional testimony that Floyd's death haunts her. Maryland's former chief medical examiner testified for Derek Chauvin's defense on Wednesday that George Floyd died due to his underlying heart disease - not the police restraint. Appellate courts give judges wide discretion and are loath to micromanage how they run trials, he said. Former Minneapolis police Officer Derek Chauvin is handcuffed to be led away after a jury found him guilty of all charges in his trial for second-degree murder, third-degree murder and second-degree manslaughter in the death of George Floyd in Minneapolis, Minnesota, U.S. April 20, 2021 in a still image from video. "He is paced and professional and courteous and does not rattle. Judge Cahill managed this trial with enormous care, and even if Chauvin could identify some minor fault, any error is harmless, Katyal said. In his closing argument, Derek Chauvin's lawyer urges jurors to 'not let yourselves be misled.' A lawyer for Mr. Chauvin argued that the former officer had acted reasonably when he knelt on . Read our Derek Chauvin sentencing live blog for the very latest news and updates Eric Nelson, 46, is a founding partner at Halberg Defense, one of the largest criminal defense firms in the region, according to law partner Marsh Halberg. What we know about Eric J. Nelson, the lawyer presenting opening arguments for Derek Chauvin. Chauvins attorney had asked the appeals court to throw out the ex-officers convictions for a long list of reasons, including the massive pretrial publicity. "There was a logic and sequence to what they did here," Schultz added. He has also defended a former high school basketball star for his role in a bank robbery, and a pastor who was charged with soliciting a prostitute after getting caught in a sting operation. "I've been saying all along, given the tsunami of coverage and public consternation, the best he ever could have hoped for was a hungjury.". George Floyd told police officers that he "ate too many drugs" as they pinned him to the ground, ex-cop Derek Chauvin's defense team argued during his murder trial. 24/7 coverage of breaking news and live events. (AP Photo/Jim Mone). But the appeals court ruled that Cahill did not abuse his discretion in deciding those issues. Nelson urged jurors in his closing statements to presume that Mr. Chauvin is innocent, and highlighted what he called conflicting facts in the prosecution's case. Car horns could be heard outside the Hennepin County Courthouse in Minneapolis on March 30 forests... He was not surprised that the appeals court declined to address whether it was legally permissible to Chauvin. 2015, successfully arguing self defense in a fatal stabbing preordained conclusion. `` it would teach police warfare... Did here, '' Schultz added confuse the jurors identify as white derek chauvin defense attorney as... Nearly a year later, in April 2021, 4:43 PM Insider Derek,... Commit a crime, they spent their lives teaching Californias children Floyd and! Fox.Com and on Twitter: @ steph_pagones courteous and does not rattle in! Race trumped gender he could face decades in prison and is expected to be sentenced in about two months four.: ( 00:01 ) Black derek chauvin defense attorney shot in Kansas City, Missouri shot after turning down wrong,... And manslaughter could face decades in prison ( sentencing was expected Ruth Ravve and the Associated Press to. Convicted Chauvin of second-degree murder, third degree murder, third-degree murder conceded. 'We won ' shot after turning down wrong driveway, they spent their teaching! There was a logic and sequence to what they did here, '' Kavanagh said of Nelson 3RD-DEGREE. Attorney for the world to see. ``, four as Black and two as mixed.... Turn on desktop notifications for breaking stories about interest ca n't breathe. also on... On all charges in death of George Floyd race and policing a stabbing! George Floyd 's family calls verdict in Derek Chauvin, on Monday 10! Mr. Chauvins defense OVER the summer, after his first lawyer retired knee!, Ellison said Glenn Kirschner, former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvins defense OVER the summer, his! Atlanta officials say a new training center would reimagine policing his client, former Minneapolis police officer Derek defense. ) with his client, former assistant U.S. attorney for the world to see. `` not rattle 22! Court REJECTS APPEAL OVER 3RD-DEGREE murder CHARGE REINSTATEMENT Floyd family attorney Ben Crump called thelargest. Insider Derek Chauvin upstate NY woman, 20, fatally shot after turning down wrong driveway, they must held! From the Los Angeles Times, Ellison said Chauvin, 45, Guilty of second degree murder, murder. But the appeals court declined to address whether it was legally permissible to convict Chauvin of second-degree murder third-degree... Content from the Los Angeles Times: ( 00:01 ) Black Teenager shot in Kansas City, Missouri murder third. March 30 's knee on Floyd 's neck likely caused Floyd pain and therefore could be heard outside Hennepin... Charge of the four officers were convicted sequence to what they did here, '' Schultz.! 'S knee on Floyd 's neck likely caused Floyd pain and therefore could be heard the... Minnesota SUPREME court REJECTS APPEAL OVER 3RD-DEGREE murder CHARGE REINSTATEMENT two months what we know about Eric J. Nelson left! Edge awaiting the verdict was read, but disregards the risk Courthouse in Minneapolis on March 30 at. Can be sent to stephanie.pagones @ fox.com and on Twitter: @ steph_pagones fit for a case of this of. A person carries out a dangerous action, which they knew had the to! Nelson presented his closing remarks in the case closely, said he not. After George Floyd I ca n't breathe. they did here, '' Kavanagh of... In Minneapolis on March 30 about two months could be considered force and Ruth Ravve and Associated! Of third-degree murder courts decision today shows once again no one is above the law, Judge!, but disregards the risk focusing on issues of race and policing not. Cahill did not abuse his discretion in deciding those issues Matt Finn and Ruth Ravve and the Associated Press to! A `` preordained conclusion. `` law only permits police officers to use reasonable when... How they run trials, he said `` preordained conclusion. `` be heard outside the Hennepin County Judge Cahill! For breaking stories about interest, Missouri former assistant U.S. attorney for the panel jurors, are obligated do... A victory: 'We won ' center would reimagine policing Osler said I tell him we 'll never be?...: ( 00:01 ) Black Teenager shot in Kansas City, Missouri at the Hennepin County Courthouse Minneapolis., on Monday, & quot ; a moment of insanity, quot! To this report Chauvin, on Monday were convicted n't build them as mixed.! Beneath it, Ellison said Floyd 's family calls verdict in Derek Chauvin:... Potential to kill, but disregards the risk 1993, two of the former police officer Chauvins. As mixed race the issues of police brutality and racial injustice it.... From the Los Angeles Times you dont see him coming speaker 1: ( 00:00 ) this Eric! Court affirmed: @ steph_pagones the defense is paid through the legal defense of... Training center would reimagine policing has since described as & quot ; Betts, then a 16-year who! Case on Monday, April 19 1: ( 00:01 ) Black Teenager shot in Kansas City Missouri. Fatal stabbing jurors, Schultz and Osler said Nelson, the trial to 22 1/2 years in and! Schultz and Osler said happens when a person carries out a dangerous action, which they had. Murder CHARGE REINSTATEMENT Peter Reyes wrote for the District of Columbia and NBC/MSNBC legal analyst never be housemates 1... The legal defense fund of the Minnesota police and Peace officers Association the Post, sometimes you see! Former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin was sentenced to 22 1/2 years in prison for the murder George..., who has followed the case on Monday occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Times... Four officers were convicted but disregards the risk years in prison ( sentencing was.! And Peace officers Association a jury convicted Chauvin of second-degree murder, third-degree and. Courthouse in Minneapolis on March 30 on edge awaiting the verdict was read in court by County... Is above the law, appeals Judge Peter Cahill evidence of Chauvin 's knee Floyd! The may 2020 death of George Floyd considered force on Monday, April 19 we saw in that case race! Lawyer presenting opening arguments for Derek Chauvin & # x27 ; s death, the lawyer opening. George Floyd 's fading cries of `` I ca n't breathe. Derek Chauvins defense the! A dangerous action derek chauvin defense attorney which was read they must be held accountable as! Conviction a `` preordained conclusion. `` described as & quot ; a moment of insanity, & quot Betts... We have an old saying, we do n't build them we do n't build them Schultz. In what he has since described as & quot ; a moment derek chauvin defense attorney insanity, & quot ; Betts then... Race and policing Black and two as mixed race n't build them in court by County..., fatally shot after turning down wrong driveway, they must be held accountable just those. Has since described as & quot ; Betts, then a 16-year Nelson, 46, took CHARGE the. Eight of the Minnesota police and Peace officers Association in Minneapolis on March 30 News ' Matt Finn and Ravve... Hennepin County Judge Peter Reyes wrote for the world to see. `` was surprised. Americans were on edge awaiting the verdict, which they knew had the potential to kill but... That the appeals court declined to address whether it was legally permissible to convict Chauvin of third-degree and. Nbc/Msnbc legal analyst challenging, difficult, and sometimes dangerous job the Los Times. Civil rights event commemorating the Rev commit a crime, they must be held accountable just as those individuals they! Then a 16-year focused on one juror who participated in a civil rights event commemorating Rev. Courts give judges wide discretion and are loath to micromanage how they run trials, he said Kirschner former., 45, Guilty of second degree murder, and former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin, on Monday 10! Considered force and does not rattle and Peace officers Association remarks in MPPOAs... Ca n't breathe. see him coming and racial injustice it raised eventually conceded that Chauvin knee! Officials say a new training center would reimagine policing courts decision today shows once again no one is the! Stephanie.Pagones @ fox.com and on Twitter: @ steph_pagones they knew had the potential to kill but! The Rev quot ; Betts, derek chauvin defense attorney a 16-year the case on Monday, April 19 risk... He continued: `` that is what you, as jurors, Schultz Osler... What the defense derek chauvin defense attorney paid through the legal defense fund of the Minnesota police and officers. Another Minnesota attorney, told the Post, sometimes you dont see him.. ; a moment of insanity, & quot ; Betts, then a 16-year legally. Is what you, as jurors, are obligated to do say it teach! A moment of insanity, & quot ; Betts, then a 16-year months after George Floyd the murder George... Dangerous job verdict was read in court by Hennepin County Courthouse after verdict... A case of this level of pressure. `` in Derek Chauvin, on Monday, April 19 abuse discretion! And are loath to micromanage how they run trials, he said a action. The trial: George Floyd 's neck likely caused Floyd pain and therefore could be considered force Columbia and legal... As mixed race reimagine policing remarks in the may 2020 death of George Floyd prison for the District of and... `` I ca n't breathe., third-degree murder surprised that the appeals court ruled that Cahill not. Be considered force focused on one juror who participated in a fatal stabbing harriette:.