I also know that Sodium Bisulfate is not the preferred choice for maintaining pH in a pool. Here is a case study by Que Hales of onBalance trying to remove it from a pool in Arizona: Total Alkalinity vs. pH and their roles in water chemistry, dissolve calcium chloride in a bucket of water, https://www.pwtag.org/sulphate-attack-february-2011/, Durability of Concrete and Cement Composites, Report on the Corrosion of Certain Alloys, https://aquamagazine.com/service/the-mystery-of-the-pointed-crystals.html, The difference between muriatic acid and sulfuric acid. We can convert in reverse to double-check our math. As long as you handle it with appropriate care, youre not in any danger. pH Down and pH Decreaser is an umbrella term, most often used in the pool and spa industry, that includes any product that can lower the pH of pool or spa water. We may earn a small commission. One pound of sodium bisulfate leaves behind 9.6 ppm of sulfate in 10,000 gallons of water. That would only occur in water with a pH near 2 or below since that is the pKa of sodium bisulfate. Liquid muriatic acid (hydrochloric acid diluted to 20 percent) and dry sodium bisulfate are among the most popular choices. Can't say enough. On average, a gallon of muriatic acid costs roughly $20 to $25. Everyday low prices, save up to 50%. 12th Annual Year End Savings Event! Scoop water out of your hot tub into an 8 gal (30.28 L) plastic bucket until that container is three-quarters full. I understand your caution but lets try to be sensible about chemicals.

Re: High pH and High Total Alkalinity- use Muriatic acid or not? For most pools, muriatic acid is probably the better option as it doesnt add sulfates to the water. Here is a case study by Que Hales of onBalance trying to remove it from a pool in Arizona: https://aquamagazine.com/service/the-mystery-of-the-pointed-crystals.html. This partly explains why sodium bisulfate costs more than muriatic acid. However it is also very corrosive and needs to be both handled and added very carefully. AJH Trade Group Australia Pool Equipment | Pool Lifestyle | Pool Heating | Pool Maintenance | Pool Problems, Acid Blue Muriatic Acid Swimming Pool pH Reducer Balancer 1 Gallon, In The Swim pH Reducer 50 lb Bag Sodium Bisulfate pH Down. This requires approximately 12 ounces (354 mL) of 31% strength muriatic acid or 16 ounces of sodium bisulfate granules. At the end of the day, just know that whichever option you choose, youll be sure to have your pH back down to normal; its just a matter of time (literally). Commercial pools have brands like, Do not add undissolved sodium bisulfate to your pool. Perhaps youve recently tested your pool water chemistry and noticed that the pH and alkalinity are too high, so youre trying to find the best ways to lower them. Any new postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members.

CO, is injected using pressurized tanks and a feeder system. Make sure that the pump and filters are running. I will use it sparingly, and thanks for the dilution tip. As a result, the water quality deteriorates, causing build-up and other problems in the hot tub. If the water pH is higher than this ideal range, the water is too basic or alkaline.

The pH will drop faster than the alkalinity, so you need to fix the alkalinity first. They are typically sold in both a 30% concentration version (at pool stores) and a 15% concentration version (at hardware stores). Because its difficult to compare a liquid acid and a granular acid that comes in different concentrations, we should look at this from a cost-per-dose perspective to see how much each would cost when theyre both trying to lower the pH. - EPA.gov, This is a far more serious problem than the carbonate scale for two reasons. than our process. Allow the pump to circulate the water for three to six hours after you add the decreaser. July 2001. Give the water a chance to balance. I assume that by corrosive you mean to skin and surrounding structures and not to the internal plumbing and mechanics of the tub, correct? Hot Tubs, Swim Spas, Patio Sets, Gazebos and More, Hours: Though durable and versatile, gunite pools are highly vulnerable to sulfate damage, thus the best option is to use muriatic acid. Test the total alkalinity of the hot tub. Per its namesake, a major component of sodium bisulfate is sulfates. It is being practiced by thousands of pool owners just like you. In this article, Ill be helping you compare and contrast the two most common chemicals used to lower pH and alkalinity, muriatic acid and sodium bisulfate, so you can decide which option is best for you. In this case, say were trying to lower the pH from 7.9 to 7.5. The lifespan of the hot tub's filter will also decrease. Lets first take a look at what these chemicals are individually so that you can have a better sense of the comparisons Ill be discussing later on. So yes, for an equivalent dose, sodium bisulfate leaves behind 2.15x the sulfates than sulfuric acid does. It may not display this or other websites correctly. Monday - Saturday 9:00am - 3:00pm, Service Phone Lines: Because fiberglass is constructed using small glass threads, polyester resin, and weather-resistant gel, its much less prone to damage caused by sulfates. Slowly pour the diluted decreaser into the center of the hot tub. In this sense, pH reduction products include both muriatic acid and sodium bisulfate. Test the water chemistry to see how much youll need to add; Based on the manufacturers instructions, calculate how much muriatic acid youll need to add to lower the pH to the normal range; Add your muriatic acid while keeping your filter running. Start out slow and take your time. New to the spa world. Login with username, password and session length. The container doesnt state the concentration of sodium bisulfate versus other ingredients. Fast service, knowledgeable, reliable and affordable! Sunday: 12:00pm-5:00pm, Hours: You are using an out of date browser. The local spa store sold me some "pH down", which is sodium bisulfite. Vinyl pools are characterized by having a sheet of vinyl between the water and the pool structure. Muriatic acid is more dangerous though. The cost of sodium bisulfate, like that of muriatic acid, depends on the amount and concentration of the product. You must log in or register to reply here. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Muriatic acid and sodium bisulfate both have their pros and cons. Total alkalinity should be tested before the pH. Periodically drain the water. Please consider. As a general rule, you will need 1.6 lbs (725.75 g) sodium bisulfate or 1.3 qt (1.23 L) muriatic acid for every 10,000 gallons (37.85 kL) of water to drop the total alkalinity by 10 ppm. Always follow the instructions on your pH/alkalinity chemical when preparing the correct amount. Signs of high alkalinity include the formation of scales along the sides and bottom of the tub, cloudy water, skin irritation, eye irritation, and poor sanitary conditions. The average cost of sodium bisulfate for a 2-pound bucket is $18. Muriatic acid appears most often as a liquid acid that is commercially produced and sold in 1-gallon jugs. Thanks, TMan. Since it is in liquid form, its easier to spill. Heres how to use muriatic acid to lower the pH in your pool. Doesnt come with clear instructions on how to use it. Here are some of the best-reviewed products on the market right now: Muriatic acid is cheaper per dose to lower pool pH and total alkalinity. During this time, the pumps should circulate the water and acid together more thoroughly. Pouring the acid into the bucket first and adding the water can cause damage to the bucket and may result in ineffective mixing. AJH Trade Group also participate in other affiliate programs. As mentioned in our earlier example, it takes roughly a pound of sodium bisulfate to lower the pH by about 0.4. Assuming the cost of muriatic acid and sodium bisulfate is $20 per gallon and $18 for 2 pounds respectively, that means well be spending $7 on muriatic acid and $9 on sodium bisulfate. If you use our referring links, it costs you nothing extra. Muriatic acid is more efficient but dangerous to handle and sodium bisulfate is safer but more expensive. Because the sulfates from sodium bisulfate are notorious for damaging concrete surfaces once theyre above 300 ppm, its safer to use sodium bisulfate in either a fiberglass or vinyl pool. We are a registered 501(c)3 non-profit that is funded by user donations. The pH may not be balanced yet, however. It is crucial, however, that no one is in the hot tub while you are balancing the water. First and foremost, unlike the. of 38.5% sulfuric acid = 1.00 fl.oz. It also creates toxic fumes. process calls for industry-standard muriatic acid (31.45% HCl). acid): Chem geek- thank you for the correction and for sharing your knowledge. Hot Tub Cyanuric Acid (Stabilizer) High | How to Lower, How to Fix a Slimy Feeling Hot Tub (Clear Biofilm), Vapor reduction technology reduces 90% of harmful vapors that come with traditional muriatic acid, The difference between this and traditional muriatic acid is not very noticeableStings the eyes even though fumes are reduced, Very quick and efficient (works in under 15 minutes), Fumes can be quite intense (a mask is recommended). All Rights Reserved. Everything Hot Tubz 2022. Understand the relationship between pH and total alkalinity. 1 pound (16 oz.) Here's an excerpt from their report: In some cases, sulfates seem to aggravate the effects of chlorides. It is most common in commercial pools with chemical automation controllers. In my pool, I use MA and a stenner pump because I'm scared of the MA and prefer to only handle it once / year. A sodium bisulfate pool system generally involves a specialized feeder to dissolve the acid in the water, then feed the acidic solution into circulation. The bottom line: sulfates destroy concrete, even if the LSI is balanced. With a bit of chemistry knowledge and some research, I learned that sodium bisulfite reacts with water to form sulfuric acid and sodium hydroxide, the latter of which is a weak alkali. Hence, muriatic acid comes out as the cheaper of the two. in the pool industry. Use a non fuming version of MA. no, do not use sulfuric or sodium bisulfate in the Orenda Startup process. This time, instead of converting to one sulfuric gallon, let's convert to one pound of sodium bisulfate: 1 pound of 93.2% sodium bisulfate = 12.1 fl.oz. Sodium bisulfate appears in granular form and is commercially produced and typically sold by the bucket. Even quite low concentrations of chlorides can cause corrosion when concentrated by occlusion in surface films." Note that if you see corrosion, etched plaster, or stained plaster, the pH and alkalinity are probably too low. This means that to lower the pH any more will mean additional sodium bisulfate and therefore, more sulfates to your pool water. Once you balance the alkalinity, the pH will gradually adjust to it. When the alkalinity and pH get too high, chlorine-based disinfectants are less effective. Muriatic acid is a highly corrosive and hazardous chemical that is the diluted version of hydrochloric acid. So that begs the question: is sulfuric acid appropriate for startups? From this, you can see that to lower the pH of a 17,000-gallon (77,284 L) pool from 7.9 to 7.5 will require $7 if youre using muriatic acid and $9 if youre using sodium bisulfate. About 1-1/2 teaspoons buy a small volume squirt bottle (they sell then on amazon) or a dispensing container with a chamber -. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. For a general idea, here are some of the most common muriatic acid products on the market. Your chemistry is wrong. You will get much more visibility by. Monday to Friday: 10:00am-6:00pm This site is owned and operated by AJH Trade Group. , and especially do not let it sit on the pool surface. Which Chlorine to Use for Vinyl Liner Pools? Sodium bisulfate does not create sulfuric acid and sodium hydroxide in water at typical spa pH. Muratic Acid is very good at lowering both PH and TA. of 31.45% HCl. Mix the chemical together with a small amount of water. Only after the two have been well combined will the pH and alkalinity be consistent throughout the hot tub, and you need to wait until these measurements are consistent before moving on any further. Fewer hydrogen ions will cause the pH to spike. Hello , This is an inactive thread. It would be 10 Baume or 15%. Test the alkalinity first, then the pH. Now I will feel better using the sodium bisulfate. Muriatic acid leaves behind chlorides (Cl, One gallon of sulfuric acid leaves behind 47.1 ppm sulfates in 10,000 gallons of water. When using either chemical, acid-resistant gloves, long sleeve clothing, and safety glasses should be used. The ideal pH range for hot tub water is between 7.4 and 7.6, but the acceptable range is between 7.2 and 7.8. Ed and Johnny went above and beyond what was expected. Master pool chemistry with the Orenda pool chemical dosing calculator. 9.6 4.45 = 2.15.

Huge Discounts on Slightly Blemished and Open Box Hot Tubs and Swim Spas! JavaScript is disabled. The reason is simple: TFPC (Trouble Free Pool Care) is a methodology, not a product that you must purchase. The lower concentration will mean very little odor and a larger quantity to measure out. Related Reading: What Is Muriatic Acid for in a Pool? Pour the acid in gradually instead of dumping it in all at once. We do not want to complicate the already-delicate water balance by introducing corrosive sulfates when the plaster is in its infancy. You could also look for a generic pH decreaser, alkalinity decreaser, or combination decreaser chemical at a pool supply store. Okay, the math checks out. Which option you choose will ultimately depend on your needs. To do this, well be using a standard pool size, which averages about 17,000 gallons (77,284 L). The hot tub should be set at its usual temperature and speed before you continue. To lower both total alkalinity and pH, you will need to add an acid. 8:00am - 5:00pm That explains why the UK's Pool Water Treatment Advisory Group (PWTAG) advises against sodium bisulfate as a primary acid, which will segway us into our next topic. Slowly pour the acid near your return jets to let the pump circulate it; Keep your pool filter circulating to let the chemical dissipate (normally within an hour); Retest your water chemistry after an hour or two. If either the alkalinity or pH is still high, repeat the process. You will need to balance the pH and alkalinity of your water nearly every week if you use the hot tub regularly. Once you notice this difficulty, it is time for you to change the old water out for fresh water. An example is some inground pools and many above-ground pools. Rapid changes in he pH are often symptomatic of low alkalinity, as well. EPA Office of Prevention, Pesticides and Toxic Substances. The main difference is the byproduct left behind. High levels of sulphate would otherwise react with and erode materials containing Portland cement, [emphasis added, and the original quote had SO, , which we will explain in a moment. High pH and High Total Alkalinity- use Muriatic acid or not? Walk-ins More precisely, pH is a measure of the concentration of hydrogen ions in the water. Afterward, fill the hot tub back up, balance the pH and alkalinity as needed, and continue to monitor the conditions as usual. Both sodium bisulfate and muriatic acid are dangerous chemicals and should be handled with care. This means the rest of the pool structure is much less likely to be damaged by the sulfates from dry acid. Know the signs of high alkalinity and high pH. Thats why its best to avoid sodium bisulfate and use muriatic acid instead. Sodium bisulfate, also known as dry acid, is a safer and less corrosive alternative to muriatic acid. Its available only in 93% concentration. Similarly, the acid reacts with bicarbonates in the water and reduces the water's total alkalinity in the process. If you need to make further adjustments, the sulfates can easily pile up and, because theyre quite difficult to remove, youll likely see the effects of the sulfates on your pool much sooner than youd expected. As a general rule, you add about 10 ppm worth of sulfates for every pound of sodium sulfate you use in a 10,000-gallon (45,461 L) pool. Determine your initial measurements based on total alkalinity. Additionally, muriatic acid works faster and is cheaper per dose. Since the two are so closely connected, you will often need to correct both at the same time. The pH of the water is essentially a measure of the level of acidity in the water. Test the pH and alkalinity of your pool water so that you know how much you need to lower it; Follow the manufacturers directions to see how much sodium bisulfate youll need; Pour the product into the water near the return jets and deepest end of your pool, while keeping your pumping running; Let your pools filtration system circulate and dissolve the product in the water; Retest the water chemistry within 24 hours and repeat if necessary. See the. Usually, if the sulfate level in your pool water exceeds 300 ppm, the water will start to attack and corrode concrete pool surfaces, metal components (including saltwater generators), and vinyl pool liners. Website Design by Sitewired Web Solutions. 2 H2O. The acid combines with the water, thereby increasing the concentration of hydrogen ions and lowering the pH. Adding the acid too quickly can cause damage to the sides, bottom, and equipment in the hot tub. That's more than double (2.1x) the sulfates for an equivalent dose of acid! Pour the full amount of pH decreaser into the water in the bucket and let it dissolve. Turn the hot tub on. Add the diluted chemical to the hot tub. The reason is that gunite is built using a rebar framework that is covered in a concrete and sand mixture. Shop Perfect Pourz at the Amazon Dining & Entertaining store. Dilute it with water first in a bucket then add it to your spa. When the alkalinity of the water becomes high or low, the pH will follow shortly after. Additionally, its stronger and will cause more damage to surfaces or body parts if its spilled or splashed. Saturday: 9:00am-5:00pm I don't keep and acid around outside of the acid that's in the container that the stenner pump pulls from. AJH Trade Group is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. Related Reading: Which Chlorine to Use for Vinyl Liner Pools? So, while this product is good at lowering the pH by virtue of the sulfuric acid, it either does nothing for or increases TA by virtue of the NaOH it adds to the water. Concrete is vulnerable to damage spawning from high sulfate concentrated water. Here, Ill be providing you with a quick guide on using sodium bisulfate to lower the pH in your pool. CO. 1.02 fl.oz. The bucket is covered with a bag so it can be closed after use. Quote from: Gassy on January 29, 2014, 07:45:28 pm, Quote from: keat63 on January 30, 2014, 09:36:03 am. sulphate ions can migrate into the cement mortars, renders, screeds or concrete and begin to react. Total alkalinity is a measure of the water's ability to buffer and resist changes to the pH.

I have gotten full strength MA on my skin many times and I assure you Im not a zombie extra on the set of The Walking Dead. Related Reading: How to Lower the pH in your Pool. Muriatic acid costs $7 per dose whilst sodium bisulfate costs $9 per dose. This means that every time you add sodium bisulfate to your pool water, you increase the sulfate concentration in the water. To decide which to use, youll have to think about your priorities: are you more focused on getting the pH down quickly, are you on a budget, or are you more worried about your safety? As the topic title states, I have a situation where my TA is very high as is my pH. The guys at Everything Hot Tubz were Fabulous! Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Most visitors online was 3404 , on Jan 24 2020, Amazon.com | Perfect Pourz 8 ounce Plastic Liquor Flask - Small Flasks with a Built-in 1/2 Ounce Shot Glass: Flasks, Filter cleaning chemicals - SDS reviews, DIY guidance, With over 300,000 members, TFP is the largest and most influential pool & spa website on the Internet.