Perhaps, the main fear of alcohol as an ingredient comes from the apprehension that it may be drying. 
Hi Irina, I first wanted to thank you for all of your hard work and research on baby wipes. (hopefully not more at the expense of the environment than their disposal!).
Kirkland wipes have only natural ingredients like aloe and chamomile to make your skin smooth and fresh. They literally smell like poop and the smell does not dissipate. Very informative.
Conversely, cetearyl alcohol and behenyl alcohol are fatty alcohols that have a waxy texture and function as emulsifiers. However, I realize that going disposable wipe-free is very challenging and, in some cases, impossible. You are more than welcome to subscribe. To be on a safe side, I would do everything possible to reduce our babies exposure to toxins. We are an Informative website dedicated to helping customers solve their consumer-related questions from a wide range of services, products, finance, and industries In my Baby Wipes Rating List, I give fragrance a rating of 8 out of 10 (10 most toxic). Cheers! Years ago, when I started researching baby wipes, the only thing I thought important was to look for alcohol-free wipes. Please read my review of WaterWipes here: https://ireadlabelsforyou.com/waterwipes-baby-wipes-natural-or-toxic/ ~Irina. FREE 5-Day Healthy Baby ProductsE-Course! So, who makes Kirkland wipes? i do this often and figure i have diluted them significantly.
Again, thank you for your feedback! By the way, I do personalized research for the subscribers to my blog. I would love to make wipes, but its just not in my bandwidth trying to keep these 2 alive.
Well, the short answer is no because preservatives are a must in products containing water. Hi Dawn,
So, technically, residue contamination in the final product is possible. Also, check out the Healthy Baby section of the IRLFY shop for safe body care and other baby products. (Safe + Non-Toxic), link to Are Certipur Mattresses Safe? Although the place of manufacture does not affect the wipes safety rating, it will help you make an informed decision. Thank you. For instance, even chamomile and coconut oil can cause irritation in sensitive people, not to mention babies whose skin gets rubbed all the time. Great research !! I cant believe weve found a way to put soy in baby wipes!) Additionally, my free blog posts will help you find the safest laundry detergent, an effective water filter system, and safe cookware, to name a few. I had previously used Walmart Teddys brand (btw had not reaction to at all) but switched to Kirkland because of the price. Hi, do you have any experience with Nature babycare Eco-Sensitive Fragrance-Free Wipes? To clarify, while some ingredients serve to cover odor or malodor, others support the functionality and durability of a fragrance compound. The Savvy Consumer Fast Track: Mattresses, Kirkland Signature Baby Wipes Ingredients. I have been using Pampers wipes for myself for years..just so I can clean up after myself. I hope it helps. But a product containing propylene glycol will still be alcohol free. While we are in a continuous process of updating our blog posts, some need to wait a little longer for their turn to be updated. Moisturizers and natural ingredients promote smooth, supple skin. (Soys in everything nowand my oldest has a soy food allergy. In addition to being the headquarters, the Jonesboro location is a manufacturing plant continuously expanding its production. AND The new wipes stink! One of the distributors is in Plainsfield, Indiana and the other is in West Nyack, New York. Second, some babies (and adults) may have a skin reaction to phenoxyethanol, even to amounts as low as 1%. I contacted the ATTITUDE company and asked them what they do to prevent the contamination from happening between Sodium Benzoate that in combination with Citric Acid may form carcinogenic Benzene.
or dryer feeling, at leastthere seems to be less liquid in each wipe)but the price is still the same. Thanks! In Aleva Naturals baby wipes I am the most concerned about Cocamidopropyl Betaine that may be contaminated with carcinogenic Nitrosamines (http://www.ewg.org/skindeep/ingredient/701520/COCAMIDOPROPYL_BETAINE/). Nevertheless, they both can irritate a babys gentle skin. Have you heard of this brand and if yes what are your thoughts and opinion? I use the Huggies brand of wipes. My husband decided to revert to the Johnson Baby wipes. Then about 2 weeks ago I go blisters on both eye lids and it was then that I put 2 and 2 together and realised it was the wipes. Formaldehyde is a very potent toxin. Thanks! We do not know the concentration of phenoxyethanol and sodium benzoate in Kirkland Signature baby wipes. Specifically, we have investigated the fragrance free, scented, and flushable Kirkland baby wipes ingredients. (I use the scale of 0-10 with 0 as the safest and 10 as the most toxic.). However at the weekend when she was at home, it got worse! (By the way, Ive tried and love! That said, lets discuss the rest of the ingredients in Kirkland Signature baby wipes, including those in their flushable wipes. Click the link to Amazon to buy Kirkland Baby wipes, Makeup Wipes, and Cleaning Wipes. Water, aloe barbadensis leaf juice, tocopheryl acetate, disodium cocoamphodiacetate, citric acid, disodium phosphate, disodium EDTA, adjusts acidity to make the wipes more compatible with a babys skin, viscosity agent (makes the liquid thicker). Hi Jessie, please email me privately with your companys information. For starters, I have not used flushable Kirkland Signature baby wipes. It is always good to know of safe alternatives. There are affiliate links, so if you do decide to use any of them, Ill earn a small commission. this is one of the questions our readers ask a lot. Would you recommend Aleva Naturals Bamboo Wipes or Attitude Eco-Baby Wipes? Costco has partnered with Nice Pak to produce Kirkland wet wipes.
Next, theJournal of the American Academy of Dermatologydescribed cases of a fungal infection caused by a compromised skin lotion in patients. The fibers are ultrafine and ultrasoft.
I hope you will find my other posts as helpful as this one.
Anyway, Im hoping that the changes are positive since its such a different list/formula compared to the old wipesbut Im a little nervous to ask! Consider turning to our Baby Wipes Rating List e-book for help with purchasing the safest (in our opinion) product: https://ireadlabelsforyou.com/best-baby-wipes-rating-list-ebook/, Your email address will not be published. I am glad you found my Kirkland Signature Baby Wipes post helpful! Required fields are marked *. Therefore, it is a good idea to discontinue using them if your baby gets a rash or skin irritation. But in all honesty, these are the exact what I use and recommend to everyone, even my own family. No spam I promise. According to the Costco website description, they are flushable because they are made with EcoFlush technology from 100% plant-based materials. Mostly because I dont like using all those chemicals on her but also because were tryiing to do zero waste and wipes are just one more thing to throw out. Please see my post about it at http://www./formaldehyde-primer/ The amount of it is probably too small to adversely impact your babys health.
When I looked it up I happened upon ur article. For help with picking the safest diapers, turn to my unprecedented Diaper Rating List e-book. I am not saying that the contaminants are present in these baby wipes. Do you see now why I refuse to promote products that have no preservation systems? Costco makes Kirkland wet wipes in the United States and not in China. There are six manufacturing plants total and two distribution plants. It is one of my biggest sellers. i do this often and figure i have diluted them significantly. Hi, Ally: I created Baby Wipes Rating List for the purpose to organize this information and present in an actionable way. When it comes to mattresses, safety is a big concern.
Typically, consumers purchase their wipes from Costco, but you can also order Kirkland wipes online in bulk. I could not locate Earth Best baby wipes ingredients on their website. And I will take a look at the ingredients. Namely, we will look into fragrance free, scented, and flushable Kirkland baby wipes ingredients.
The only scientific articles found related benzene formation talk about ascorbic acid (vitamin C), not citric acid and sodium benzoate. Are IKEA Mattresses Certipur Certified? If you can, please check them out. Thus, theEuropean Chemicals Agencydeems it safe for dermal applications. Thank you, Ashley, for sharing this helpful information about Kirkland signature baby wipes! Thank you for your comment! Also, if you decide to flush, stick to one wipe at a time. Lindsey is based in Morgantown, West Virginia. Therefore, if your baby experiences discomfort, stop using these baby wipes. All Kirkland wipes use the ultra-soft fiber, Tencel. Youre a tremendous help! And soy protein? In a baby wipe??? My baby did develop a rash when she was around 3 months old.
Thank you again! At least they got rid of the sodium hydroxymethylglycinate from the old formula Im hoping that this means the new version is formaldehyde free! Tnis is sooo true i bought Kirkland wipes and when I used it on my son to wipe his mouth just seconds, rashes appeared on his face. (Im guessing that its a pretty benign ingredient in a baby wipe) Benzyl alcohol might be irritating to the skin for some babies, possibly, but so far I dont think its bothering my babys or my toddlers skin. That is why it is important to be aware of what the Cosmetic Ingredient Review (CIR) panel says about sodium benzoate before purchasing these Costco baby wipes. I just discovered it recently and wish I would have found it before.
It contains OH groups which are also present in alcohols. Im sure theyre just as bad as the Pampers and Kirkland but wondered if you knew for sure?
Bottom line, Kirkland Signature baby wipes have neither alcohol, nor any of the ingredients with the word alcohol in them. Ill be headed over to the honest site. the Honest baby wipes, but the price just isnt working in our budget right now with our two youngest in diapers.
The milder preservatives used in Costco baby wipes now are phenoxyethanol and sodium benzoate.
Happy Sunday! And all three kinds, including the flushable wipes, share the same preservation system phenoxyethanol and sodium benzoate. Do you use Costco baby wipes and want to know whether they are a safe choice for your baby?
Probably, it is a good idea to take into consideration the construction of your plumbing system, its age, the water pressure, and the overall sewage maintenance before flushing the wipes. When a product contains methanol or ethanol, it is labelled as contains alcohol.
Thank you, Irina, for your research and this valuable information. Kirkland wet wipes are biodegradable. Since then, Lindsey has worked in the retail and consumer service industry as a manager, advisor, and marketer.
Good Job! I am glad that you found my post useful.
And vice versa, Kirkland Signature flushable wipes contain tocopheryl acetate but no xanthan gum.
The headquarters of Nice Pak is in Jonesboro, Arkansas. These northern distribution centers assist in overseas shipments and distribution of mainland orders. Read also: Who Makes Kirkland Brand Paper Towels? I dont want to appear as if Im spamming your page though by adding my website and product info.
While I am happy about these major improvements, Kirkland baby wipes are not at the top of mybest baby wipes rating list, just yet. link to Are IKEA Mattresses Certipur Certified? As for benzyl alcohol, it is an aromatic alcohol used in cosmetic formulations as a natural preservative. Kirkland wipes are one of many products that Nice Pak distributes across the USA to Costco. That is why I created my Baby Wipes Rating List e-book to help you choose the safest baby wipes.
As a result of consumer power, these Costco baby wipes were reformulated to remove the formaldehyde-releasing preservative in 2014. As advocates for better health, Nice Pak has worked hard to create a sanitary wipe without harmful additives. Specifically, they help soften the skin and improve the texture and consistency of the formulation. Hi Carrie: I apologize for not being able to get back to you right away. I notice you mentioned that Propylene Glycol has been removed. Pingback: A Warning About Using Baby Wipes on our Dogs #DermaPet | Keep the Tail Wagging | Raising Dogs Naturally. Thank you. On the other hand, compostable materials biodegrade in a composting process within a specified timeframe and at the right temperature. The name is WaterWipes. As for tocopheryl acetate, it can be contaminated with hydroquinone due to manufacturing practices if a company does not source this ingredient of good quality. I'm Irina Webb, the trusted non-toxic consumer product researcher. Cant wait for your weekly updates!
So, I cannot tell you from my personal experience whether they are actually flushable. As a result of this communication, more and more manufacturers have begun describing their wipe material on their websites. Neither do any of the baby wipes (more than 50) included in my Baby Wipes Rating List. I believe the old-fashioned way washable rags and castile soap (I highly recommend Dr. Bronners soap >) is the healthiest and greenest alternative.
Im an old Gramma now, so I just have one pack of wipes that I keep around for the occasional need, but its interesting to know that the plain old facecloth and water that I usually reach for is still the best option. And even if it is not contaminated, I am not in favor of this ingredient because it was nominated Allergen of the Year by the dermatitis society (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18627690). I pulled a quote from the blog and linked it back to this post. ATTITUDE products do not have ascorbic acid, do not have extreme pH, are not stored/used under high temperatures and are not exposed to light.
About a month ago, when we ran out of my 1 year old daughters Johnsons baby wipes , my husband bought the Kirkland brand. Thank you so much for your website and research. Hence, the term is confusing as it does not define time limits for the process of biodegradation. Thanks for the save! Also, please read my blog post to find out if sodium benzoate and citric acid are okay when used together. Thank you in advance. We are participants in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Indeed, even the best-rated infant wipes may contain ingredients that can potentially irritate the babys gentle skin. Very easy to read, understand, and grasp. My baby broke out from them burning her bottom. My top recommendation is to use cloth wipes. Thus, in its Guide to Compostable Products and Packaging, the Association for Organics Recycling states that generally speaking, most materials biodegrade given time. I am returning the rest of the box to Costco today for a refund. No, Costco baby wipes have no alcohol among their ingredients. Although alcohol-free baby wipes is a popular search phrase, it is a myth because all baby wipes are alcohol free. Let me know if you have more questions. As I know nothing about all those chemical, I would love to hear your opinion on those ingredients.
Nice Pak is partnered with Costco to produce top-quality, sanitary wet wipes. I anticipate the post to go live in the first couple weeks of May.
Nice Pak supplies consumers across the mainland United States with high-quality sanitary wipes at an affordable price. Replies to my comments Thank you, Irina! Hope this helps! Also, with the new smaller (and less moist) wipes, Im finding that I dont get as much mileage out of each one so were going through each pack faster than the old ones. Additionally, there is a concern that the temperatures necessary to induce biodegradation may not be reached through a non-composting environment. The more of us ask questions, the sooner we will see changes in the market. Those and Honest Co seem like the best, based on the ingredients.
Best, Irina. The amount of non-biodegradable wet wipes ending up in landfills is outrageous. ~Irina. thank you for asking the question. (All You Need to Know). I'm on a mission to help you make informed and practical decisions about products you buy. All the others are tiny squares and hard to use.
That is why I had to personally contact the manufacturers with the question about their wipes material. Yes, that confirms my understanding that benzene may formed only when ascorbic acid, not citric acid, is reacted with sodium benzoate. For pee-pee bottoms, I use warm water and soap on old, softer, cut up cotton t- shirts. ~Irina. :)) However, we update our Baby Wipes Rating List E-book annually, and the ingredients for KS Baby Wipes Fragrance-Free in the e-book correspond to those on their website. Thank you for reaching out to I Read Labels for You and for reading product ingredients! However, in my Baby Wipes Rating List, I rate the wipes based on the ingredients presented on the websites, not the manufacturing practices or contaminants. To emphasize, the information about the wipe material is not that readily available on manufacturers websites. I actually work with a company that makes a great Eco friendly, money saving, chemical free alternative. Nice Pak significantly reduces this amount by creating a wipe that biodegrades itself. Wouldnt it be better to avoid preservatives altogether? Indeed, the ingredients for KS fragrance-free baby wipes today (2022) differ from those discussed in the blog post (2020). In an ideal world, it would be best to not use any disposable baby wipes. Shipping may cost additional to ship to other places like Alaska, Hawaii, and Puerto Rico. So I look at my ingredients and it is sooooo not the same now. But then again, we are talking about gentle baby bottoms that wear diapers and get wiped all day long. Regarding xanthan gum, I agree with holistic health coaches that as a food additive, it is not the best choice. I was in the process of ordering another supply when I saw your article. Unfortunately, phthalates, e.g., diethyl phthalate, are common fragrance ingredients. Stopped using them right away and about 5 -6 days later things started clearing up. For your information, the European Chemicals Agency states that diethyl phthalate is under assessment as endocrine disrupting (source). Hi, Monique: could you please email me a picture of the ingredients on the box? Propylene glycol is not an alcohol. (Check out these soft and convenient Wild & Pure Dry wipes.). The new list is as follows: Aqua (purified water), aloe barbadensis (aloe vera leaf) extract, contains less than 1% of the following: sodium cocyl hydrolyzed soy protein (cleanser), oryza sativa (rice) extract, glycerin (moisturizing cleanser), tocopherol (vitamin E), dehydroacetic acid, benzoic acid, benzyl alcohol (preservative), dimethicone copolyol (foam reducer), citric acid (pH balancer) What do you think about the new Ingredients list? I have also subscribed to your blog. I rate benzyl alcohol 3 in my Baby Wipes Rating List. So, it is a good thing that Costco baby wipes contain preservatives because they are all water-based. As a reminder, Costco baby wipes list fragrance as an ingredient only in the scented version of Kirkland baby wipes. I am glad that you find my research helpful.
Thanks for doing the research and putting it out there so us other mommies can make better choices for our kids and the environment! In 2014, I wrote a critical review on them, and several years later my suspicions appeared to be right. Just thought I would let you know since there is definitely not aloe or any of the other soothing ingredients listed on my package of signature Kirkland baby wipes. Nice Pak is a global leader in sanitation innovation who believes in sustainability, good health, and a clean environment. To sum up, in this expert baby wipes ingredient review, you have learned about three kinds of Costco baby wipes. https://www.costco.com/kirkland-signature-baby-wipes-fragrance-free%2C-900-count.product.100801219.html. However, reading this latest article, I havent seen anything about prices. On the one hand, as I have written in my post on Phenoxyethanol in Skin Care, phenoxyethanol is not carcinogenic and is not an endocrine disruptor. Why so high? Nice Pak is a company dedicated to the health and safety of its consumers. Mainland and overseas customers can choose express shipment on any order for an additional charge.
I have 2 year old twin boys and have been using the buggies natural care wipes and am so sad to read that I might have been poisoning my babies. Kirkland wet wipes are biodegradable, which means they are a zero-waste product. I have a question about certain baby wipes I just recently came across. Soon after we started using the new wipes, my daughter had a really bad skin reaction (rashes, raw skin, etc.). Great article! Among disposable wipes, I recommend Honest Baby Wipes or making your own cloth wipes. I always keep a price at the back of my mind and stay away from unreasonably expensive things. Thank you, Marie, for your research! Besides, the European Chemicals Agency warns that ethylene oxide is mutagenic, toxic to reproduction, and under assessment as endocrine disrupting. Summary of the Kirkland Signature Baby Wipes Post, European Chemicals Agency warns that ethylene oxide, list of allergens maintained by the American Contact Dermatitis Society, American Journal of Infection Controlreported an outbreak of an infection, Journal of the American Academy of Dermatologydescribed cases of a fungal infection, Journal of Hospital Infectionreported numerous infections, International Fragrance Association Transparency List, Guide to Compostable Products and Packaging, Association for Organics Recycling emphasizes, http://www.ewg.org/skindeep/ingredient/701520/COCAMIDOPROPYL_BETAINE/, http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18627690, http://www.ewg.org/skindeep/ingredient/700697/BENZYL_ALCOHOL/, http://www.ewg.org/skindeep/ingredient/726354/BENZENE/, http://www.ireadlabelsforyou.com/toxin-free-baby-wipes-not-made-in-china/, https://ireadlabelsforyou.com/waterwipes-baby-wipes-natural-or-toxic/, https://ireadlabelsforyou.com/best-baby-wipes-rating-list-ebook/. and maybe a tad thinner, too? Great article..thank you for your research. Ive been using them for 2 months now and my baby hadnt had any reactions that Ive noticed. When I receive the email and I will let you know what I think about the wipes. I will try to be more explicit about prices in my upcoming posts. In short, the ingredients have improved significantly, as now there are no formaldehyde-releasing preservatives and potentially allergenic propylene glycol. Thanks! Alternatively, cotton is rated 1, and polypropylene (aka plastic of recycle code 5) is rated 10. I have been a BIG user of Kirklands baby wipes. Weve used Earths Best, as they were on sale. My review for the baby wipes This wet wipe company is recognized globally as one of the most successful sanitation companies. (?). (Usually Johnsons but I will be switching to castile soap now.) I mostly use Honest wipes but buy Earths Best also. Moreover, a US consultant, David Steinberg, told: the formation of benzene by a reaction between citric acid and sodium benzoate is an urban legend with no basis in reality. A Word on Tocopheryl Acetate and Xanthan Gum. Consequently, the biological processes during composting yield C02, water, inorganic compounds, and biomass with no visible contaminants or toxic substances.
In all of the comments, the formation is only possible under very specific conditions such as extreme pH and/or elevated temperature and/or UV light. I just wanted to add that actually you can buy the honest companys wipes at nordstrom!! We wipe their hands every time before they eat. And babies are especially vulnerable because their detox systems are not fully developed yet. There are an additional two distribution centers located in the Northern United States. Not realising it was caused by the Kirkland wipes and being very concerned, I took my daughter to the doctor several times. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Welcome to rvandplaya.com. Convenience is cheap for the pocket book but potentially costly to our health. (By the way, I have seen many changes in product formulations thanks to consumer power. Hi, I had been using the Kirkland Baby Wipes for about a year for my own personal hygiene and to take off my make-up. As for the flushable Costco baby wipes, the packaging says they are made with EcoFlush Technology from 100% plant-based materials.. In the meantime, the International Fragrance Association Transparency List includes more than 3000 fragrance ingredients. Or at least that is what the box says. As a broad-spectrum preservative, phenoxyethanol prevents both mold and bacteria growth in baby wipes that contain water.
True, there exist ingredients that contain the word alcohol in their names, such as cetearyl alcohol, behenyl alcohol, and benzyl alcohol. In my Baby Wipes Rating List, I give Tencel as a plant-based material a rating of 5 out of 10. It is chemically impossible for a salt (sodium benzoate) to react with an acid (citric or any other) to form a hydrocarbon (benzene).. Here is their reply for anyone interested in those baby wipes: Regarding concerns about benzene formation related to sodium or potassium benzoate, our supplier certifies that this ingredient does not contain any Benzene nor does it contain any Benzene during the production process.
Hi Irina, I first wanted to thank you for all of your hard work and research on baby wipes. (hopefully not more at the expense of the environment than their disposal!). Kirkland wipes have only natural ingredients like aloe and chamomile to make your skin smooth and fresh. They literally smell like poop and the smell does not dissipate. Very informative.
Conversely, cetearyl alcohol and behenyl alcohol are fatty alcohols that have a waxy texture and function as emulsifiers. However, I realize that going disposable wipe-free is very challenging and, in some cases, impossible. You are more than welcome to subscribe. To be on a safe side, I would do everything possible to reduce our babies exposure to toxins. We are an Informative website dedicated to helping customers solve their consumer-related questions from a wide range of services, products, finance, and industries In my Baby Wipes Rating List, I give fragrance a rating of 8 out of 10 (10 most toxic). Cheers! Years ago, when I started researching baby wipes, the only thing I thought important was to look for alcohol-free wipes. Please read my review of WaterWipes here: https://ireadlabelsforyou.com/waterwipes-baby-wipes-natural-or-toxic/ ~Irina. FREE 5-Day Healthy Baby ProductsE-Course! So, who makes Kirkland wipes? i do this often and figure i have diluted them significantly.
Again, thank you for your feedback! By the way, I do personalized research for the subscribers to my blog. I would love to make wipes, but its just not in my bandwidth trying to keep these 2 alive.
Well, the short answer is no because preservatives are a must in products containing water. Hi Dawn,
So, technically, residue contamination in the final product is possible. Also, check out the Healthy Baby section of the IRLFY shop for safe body care and other baby products. (Safe + Non-Toxic), link to Are Certipur Mattresses Safe? Although the place of manufacture does not affect the wipes safety rating, it will help you make an informed decision. Thank you. For instance, even chamomile and coconut oil can cause irritation in sensitive people, not to mention babies whose skin gets rubbed all the time. Great research !! I cant believe weve found a way to put soy in baby wipes!) Additionally, my free blog posts will help you find the safest laundry detergent, an effective water filter system, and safe cookware, to name a few. I had previously used Walmart Teddys brand (btw had not reaction to at all) but switched to Kirkland because of the price. Hi, do you have any experience with Nature babycare Eco-Sensitive Fragrance-Free Wipes? To clarify, while some ingredients serve to cover odor or malodor, others support the functionality and durability of a fragrance compound. The Savvy Consumer Fast Track: Mattresses, Kirkland Signature Baby Wipes Ingredients. I have been using Pampers wipes for myself for years..just so I can clean up after myself. I hope it helps. But a product containing propylene glycol will still be alcohol free. While we are in a continuous process of updating our blog posts, some need to wait a little longer for their turn to be updated. Moisturizers and natural ingredients promote smooth, supple skin. (Soys in everything nowand my oldest has a soy food allergy. In addition to being the headquarters, the Jonesboro location is a manufacturing plant continuously expanding its production. AND The new wipes stink! One of the distributors is in Plainsfield, Indiana and the other is in West Nyack, New York. Second, some babies (and adults) may have a skin reaction to phenoxyethanol, even to amounts as low as 1%. I contacted the ATTITUDE company and asked them what they do to prevent the contamination from happening between Sodium Benzoate that in combination with Citric Acid may form carcinogenic Benzene.
or dryer feeling, at leastthere seems to be less liquid in each wipe)but the price is still the same. Thanks! In Aleva Naturals baby wipes I am the most concerned about Cocamidopropyl Betaine that may be contaminated with carcinogenic Nitrosamines (http://www.ewg.org/skindeep/ingredient/701520/COCAMIDOPROPYL_BETAINE/). Nevertheless, they both can irritate a babys gentle skin. Have you heard of this brand and if yes what are your thoughts and opinion? I use the Huggies brand of wipes. My husband decided to revert to the Johnson Baby wipes. Then about 2 weeks ago I go blisters on both eye lids and it was then that I put 2 and 2 together and realised it was the wipes. Formaldehyde is a very potent toxin. Thanks! We do not know the concentration of phenoxyethanol and sodium benzoate in Kirkland Signature baby wipes. Specifically, we have investigated the fragrance free, scented, and flushable Kirkland baby wipes ingredients. (I use the scale of 0-10 with 0 as the safest and 10 as the most toxic.). However at the weekend when she was at home, it got worse! (By the way, Ive tried and love! That said, lets discuss the rest of the ingredients in Kirkland Signature baby wipes, including those in their flushable wipes. Click the link to Amazon to buy Kirkland Baby wipes, Makeup Wipes, and Cleaning Wipes. Water, aloe barbadensis leaf juice, tocopheryl acetate, disodium cocoamphodiacetate, citric acid, disodium phosphate, disodium EDTA, adjusts acidity to make the wipes more compatible with a babys skin, viscosity agent (makes the liquid thicker). Hi Jessie, please email me privately with your companys information. For starters, I have not used flushable Kirkland Signature baby wipes. It is always good to know of safe alternatives. There are affiliate links, so if you do decide to use any of them, Ill earn a small commission. this is one of the questions our readers ask a lot. Would you recommend Aleva Naturals Bamboo Wipes or Attitude Eco-Baby Wipes? Costco has partnered with Nice Pak to produce Kirkland wet wipes.
Next, theJournal of the American Academy of Dermatologydescribed cases of a fungal infection caused by a compromised skin lotion in patients. The fibers are ultrafine and ultrasoft.
I hope you will find my other posts as helpful as this one.
Anyway, Im hoping that the changes are positive since its such a different list/formula compared to the old wipesbut Im a little nervous to ask! Consider turning to our Baby Wipes Rating List e-book for help with purchasing the safest (in our opinion) product: https://ireadlabelsforyou.com/best-baby-wipes-rating-list-ebook/, Your email address will not be published. I am glad you found my Kirkland Signature Baby Wipes post helpful! Required fields are marked *. Therefore, it is a good idea to discontinue using them if your baby gets a rash or skin irritation. But in all honesty, these are the exact what I use and recommend to everyone, even my own family. No spam I promise. According to the Costco website description, they are flushable because they are made with EcoFlush technology from 100% plant-based materials. Mostly because I dont like using all those chemicals on her but also because were tryiing to do zero waste and wipes are just one more thing to throw out. Please see my post about it at http://www./formaldehyde-primer/ The amount of it is probably too small to adversely impact your babys health.
When I looked it up I happened upon ur article. For help with picking the safest diapers, turn to my unprecedented Diaper Rating List e-book. I am not saying that the contaminants are present in these baby wipes. Do you see now why I refuse to promote products that have no preservation systems? Costco makes Kirkland wet wipes in the United States and not in China. There are six manufacturing plants total and two distribution plants. It is one of my biggest sellers. i do this often and figure i have diluted them significantly. Hi, Ally: I created Baby Wipes Rating List for the purpose to organize this information and present in an actionable way. When it comes to mattresses, safety is a big concern. Typically, consumers purchase their wipes from Costco, but you can also order Kirkland wipes online in bulk. I could not locate Earth Best baby wipes ingredients on their website. And I will take a look at the ingredients. Namely, we will look into fragrance free, scented, and flushable Kirkland baby wipes ingredients.
The only scientific articles found related benzene formation talk about ascorbic acid (vitamin C), not citric acid and sodium benzoate. Are IKEA Mattresses Certipur Certified? If you can, please check them out. Thus, theEuropean Chemicals Agencydeems it safe for dermal applications. Thank you, Ashley, for sharing this helpful information about Kirkland signature baby wipes! Thank you for your comment! Also, if you decide to flush, stick to one wipe at a time. Lindsey is based in Morgantown, West Virginia. Therefore, if your baby experiences discomfort, stop using these baby wipes. All Kirkland wipes use the ultra-soft fiber, Tencel. Youre a tremendous help! And soy protein? In a baby wipe??? My baby did develop a rash when she was around 3 months old.
Thank you again! At least they got rid of the sodium hydroxymethylglycinate from the old formula Im hoping that this means the new version is formaldehyde free! Tnis is sooo true i bought Kirkland wipes and when I used it on my son to wipe his mouth just seconds, rashes appeared on his face. (Im guessing that its a pretty benign ingredient in a baby wipe) Benzyl alcohol might be irritating to the skin for some babies, possibly, but so far I dont think its bothering my babys or my toddlers skin. That is why it is important to be aware of what the Cosmetic Ingredient Review (CIR) panel says about sodium benzoate before purchasing these Costco baby wipes. I just discovered it recently and wish I would have found it before.
It contains OH groups which are also present in alcohols. Im sure theyre just as bad as the Pampers and Kirkland but wondered if you knew for sure?
Bottom line, Kirkland Signature baby wipes have neither alcohol, nor any of the ingredients with the word alcohol in them. Ill be headed over to the honest site. the Honest baby wipes, but the price just isnt working in our budget right now with our two youngest in diapers.
The milder preservatives used in Costco baby wipes now are phenoxyethanol and sodium benzoate.
Happy Sunday! And all three kinds, including the flushable wipes, share the same preservation system phenoxyethanol and sodium benzoate. Do you use Costco baby wipes and want to know whether they are a safe choice for your baby?
Probably, it is a good idea to take into consideration the construction of your plumbing system, its age, the water pressure, and the overall sewage maintenance before flushing the wipes. When a product contains methanol or ethanol, it is labelled as contains alcohol.
Thank you, Irina, for your research and this valuable information. Kirkland wet wipes are biodegradable. Since then, Lindsey has worked in the retail and consumer service industry as a manager, advisor, and marketer.
Good Job! I am glad that you found my post useful.
And vice versa, Kirkland Signature flushable wipes contain tocopheryl acetate but no xanthan gum.
The headquarters of Nice Pak is in Jonesboro, Arkansas. These northern distribution centers assist in overseas shipments and distribution of mainland orders. Read also: Who Makes Kirkland Brand Paper Towels? I dont want to appear as if Im spamming your page though by adding my website and product info.
While I am happy about these major improvements, Kirkland baby wipes are not at the top of mybest baby wipes rating list, just yet. link to Are IKEA Mattresses Certipur Certified? As for benzyl alcohol, it is an aromatic alcohol used in cosmetic formulations as a natural preservative. Kirkland wipes are one of many products that Nice Pak distributes across the USA to Costco. That is why I created my Baby Wipes Rating List e-book to help you choose the safest baby wipes.
As a result of consumer power, these Costco baby wipes were reformulated to remove the formaldehyde-releasing preservative in 2014. As advocates for better health, Nice Pak has worked hard to create a sanitary wipe without harmful additives. Specifically, they help soften the skin and improve the texture and consistency of the formulation. Hi Carrie: I apologize for not being able to get back to you right away. I notice you mentioned that Propylene Glycol has been removed. Pingback: A Warning About Using Baby Wipes on our Dogs #DermaPet | Keep the Tail Wagging | Raising Dogs Naturally. Thank you. On the other hand, compostable materials biodegrade in a composting process within a specified timeframe and at the right temperature. The name is WaterWipes. As for tocopheryl acetate, it can be contaminated with hydroquinone due to manufacturing practices if a company does not source this ingredient of good quality. I'm Irina Webb, the trusted non-toxic consumer product researcher. Cant wait for your weekly updates!
So, I cannot tell you from my personal experience whether they are actually flushable. As a result of this communication, more and more manufacturers have begun describing their wipe material on their websites. Neither do any of the baby wipes (more than 50) included in my Baby Wipes Rating List. I believe the old-fashioned way washable rags and castile soap (I highly recommend Dr. Bronners soap >) is the healthiest and greenest alternative.
Im an old Gramma now, so I just have one pack of wipes that I keep around for the occasional need, but its interesting to know that the plain old facecloth and water that I usually reach for is still the best option. And even if it is not contaminated, I am not in favor of this ingredient because it was nominated Allergen of the Year by the dermatitis society (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18627690). I pulled a quote from the blog and linked it back to this post. ATTITUDE products do not have ascorbic acid, do not have extreme pH, are not stored/used under high temperatures and are not exposed to light.
About a month ago, when we ran out of my 1 year old daughters Johnsons baby wipes , my husband bought the Kirkland brand. Thank you so much for your website and research. Hence, the term is confusing as it does not define time limits for the process of biodegradation. Thanks for the save! Also, please read my blog post to find out if sodium benzoate and citric acid are okay when used together. Thank you in advance. We are participants in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Indeed, even the best-rated infant wipes may contain ingredients that can potentially irritate the babys gentle skin. Very easy to read, understand, and grasp. My baby broke out from them burning her bottom. My top recommendation is to use cloth wipes. Thus, in its Guide to Compostable Products and Packaging, the Association for Organics Recycling states that generally speaking, most materials biodegrade given time. I am returning the rest of the box to Costco today for a refund. No, Costco baby wipes have no alcohol among their ingredients. Although alcohol-free baby wipes is a popular search phrase, it is a myth because all baby wipes are alcohol free. Let me know if you have more questions. As I know nothing about all those chemical, I would love to hear your opinion on those ingredients.
Nice Pak is partnered with Costco to produce top-quality, sanitary wet wipes. I anticipate the post to go live in the first couple weeks of May.
Nice Pak supplies consumers across the mainland United States with high-quality sanitary wipes at an affordable price. Replies to my comments Thank you, Irina! Hope this helps! Also, with the new smaller (and less moist) wipes, Im finding that I dont get as much mileage out of each one so were going through each pack faster than the old ones. Additionally, there is a concern that the temperatures necessary to induce biodegradation may not be reached through a non-composting environment. The more of us ask questions, the sooner we will see changes in the market. Those and Honest Co seem like the best, based on the ingredients.
Best, Irina. The amount of non-biodegradable wet wipes ending up in landfills is outrageous. ~Irina. thank you for asking the question. (All You Need to Know). I'm on a mission to help you make informed and practical decisions about products you buy. All the others are tiny squares and hard to use.
That is why I had to personally contact the manufacturers with the question about their wipes material. Yes, that confirms my understanding that benzene may formed only when ascorbic acid, not citric acid, is reacted with sodium benzoate. For pee-pee bottoms, I use warm water and soap on old, softer, cut up cotton t- shirts. ~Irina. :)) However, we update our Baby Wipes Rating List E-book annually, and the ingredients for KS Baby Wipes Fragrance-Free in the e-book correspond to those on their website. Thank you for reaching out to I Read Labels for You and for reading product ingredients! However, in my Baby Wipes Rating List, I rate the wipes based on the ingredients presented on the websites, not the manufacturing practices or contaminants. To emphasize, the information about the wipe material is not that readily available on manufacturers websites. I actually work with a company that makes a great Eco friendly, money saving, chemical free alternative. Nice Pak significantly reduces this amount by creating a wipe that biodegrades itself. Wouldnt it be better to avoid preservatives altogether? Indeed, the ingredients for KS fragrance-free baby wipes today (2022) differ from those discussed in the blog post (2020). In an ideal world, it would be best to not use any disposable baby wipes. Shipping may cost additional to ship to other places like Alaska, Hawaii, and Puerto Rico. So I look at my ingredients and it is sooooo not the same now. But then again, we are talking about gentle baby bottoms that wear diapers and get wiped all day long. Regarding xanthan gum, I agree with holistic health coaches that as a food additive, it is not the best choice. I was in the process of ordering another supply when I saw your article. Unfortunately, phthalates, e.g., diethyl phthalate, are common fragrance ingredients. Stopped using them right away and about 5 -6 days later things started clearing up. For your information, the European Chemicals Agency states that diethyl phthalate is under assessment as endocrine disrupting (source). Hi, Monique: could you please email me a picture of the ingredients on the box? Propylene glycol is not an alcohol. (Check out these soft and convenient Wild & Pure Dry wipes.). The new list is as follows: Aqua (purified water), aloe barbadensis (aloe vera leaf) extract, contains less than 1% of the following: sodium cocyl hydrolyzed soy protein (cleanser), oryza sativa (rice) extract, glycerin (moisturizing cleanser), tocopherol (vitamin E), dehydroacetic acid, benzoic acid, benzyl alcohol (preservative), dimethicone copolyol (foam reducer), citric acid (pH balancer) What do you think about the new Ingredients list? I have also subscribed to your blog. I rate benzyl alcohol 3 in my Baby Wipes Rating List. So, it is a good thing that Costco baby wipes contain preservatives because they are all water-based. As a reminder, Costco baby wipes list fragrance as an ingredient only in the scented version of Kirkland baby wipes. I am glad that you find my research helpful.
Thanks for doing the research and putting it out there so us other mommies can make better choices for our kids and the environment! In 2014, I wrote a critical review on them, and several years later my suspicions appeared to be right. Just thought I would let you know since there is definitely not aloe or any of the other soothing ingredients listed on my package of signature Kirkland baby wipes. Nice Pak is a global leader in sanitation innovation who believes in sustainability, good health, and a clean environment. To sum up, in this expert baby wipes ingredient review, you have learned about three kinds of Costco baby wipes. https://www.costco.com/kirkland-signature-baby-wipes-fragrance-free%2C-900-count.product.100801219.html. However, reading this latest article, I havent seen anything about prices. On the one hand, as I have written in my post on Phenoxyethanol in Skin Care, phenoxyethanol is not carcinogenic and is not an endocrine disruptor. Why so high? Nice Pak is a company dedicated to the health and safety of its consumers. Mainland and overseas customers can choose express shipment on any order for an additional charge.
I have 2 year old twin boys and have been using the buggies natural care wipes and am so sad to read that I might have been poisoning my babies. Kirkland wet wipes are biodegradable, which means they are a zero-waste product. I have a question about certain baby wipes I just recently came across. Soon after we started using the new wipes, my daughter had a really bad skin reaction (rashes, raw skin, etc.). Great article! Among disposable wipes, I recommend Honest Baby Wipes or making your own cloth wipes. I always keep a price at the back of my mind and stay away from unreasonably expensive things. Thank you, Marie, for your research! Besides, the European Chemicals Agency warns that ethylene oxide is mutagenic, toxic to reproduction, and under assessment as endocrine disrupting. Summary of the Kirkland Signature Baby Wipes Post, European Chemicals Agency warns that ethylene oxide, list of allergens maintained by the American Contact Dermatitis Society, American Journal of Infection Controlreported an outbreak of an infection, Journal of the American Academy of Dermatologydescribed cases of a fungal infection, Journal of Hospital Infectionreported numerous infections, International Fragrance Association Transparency List, Guide to Compostable Products and Packaging, Association for Organics Recycling emphasizes, http://www.ewg.org/skindeep/ingredient/701520/COCAMIDOPROPYL_BETAINE/, http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18627690, http://www.ewg.org/skindeep/ingredient/700697/BENZYL_ALCOHOL/, http://www.ewg.org/skindeep/ingredient/726354/BENZENE/, http://www.ireadlabelsforyou.com/toxin-free-baby-wipes-not-made-in-china/, https://ireadlabelsforyou.com/waterwipes-baby-wipes-natural-or-toxic/, https://ireadlabelsforyou.com/best-baby-wipes-rating-list-ebook/. and maybe a tad thinner, too? Great article..thank you for your research. Ive been using them for 2 months now and my baby hadnt had any reactions that Ive noticed. When I receive the email and I will let you know what I think about the wipes. I will try to be more explicit about prices in my upcoming posts. In short, the ingredients have improved significantly, as now there are no formaldehyde-releasing preservatives and potentially allergenic propylene glycol. Thanks! Alternatively, cotton is rated 1, and polypropylene (aka plastic of recycle code 5) is rated 10. I have been a BIG user of Kirklands baby wipes. Weve used Earths Best, as they were on sale. My review for the baby wipes This wet wipe company is recognized globally as one of the most successful sanitation companies. (?). (Usually Johnsons but I will be switching to castile soap now.) I mostly use Honest wipes but buy Earths Best also. Moreover, a US consultant, David Steinberg, told: the formation of benzene by a reaction between citric acid and sodium benzoate is an urban legend with no basis in reality. A Word on Tocopheryl Acetate and Xanthan Gum. Consequently, the biological processes during composting yield C02, water, inorganic compounds, and biomass with no visible contaminants or toxic substances.
In all of the comments, the formation is only possible under very specific conditions such as extreme pH and/or elevated temperature and/or UV light. I just wanted to add that actually you can buy the honest companys wipes at nordstrom!! We wipe their hands every time before they eat. And babies are especially vulnerable because their detox systems are not fully developed yet. There are an additional two distribution centers located in the Northern United States. Not realising it was caused by the Kirkland wipes and being very concerned, I took my daughter to the doctor several times. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Welcome to rvandplaya.com. Convenience is cheap for the pocket book but potentially costly to our health. (By the way, I have seen many changes in product formulations thanks to consumer power. Hi, I had been using the Kirkland Baby Wipes for about a year for my own personal hygiene and to take off my make-up. As for the flushable Costco baby wipes, the packaging says they are made with EcoFlush Technology from 100% plant-based materials.. In the meantime, the International Fragrance Association Transparency List includes more than 3000 fragrance ingredients. Or at least that is what the box says. As a broad-spectrum preservative, phenoxyethanol prevents both mold and bacteria growth in baby wipes that contain water.
True, there exist ingredients that contain the word alcohol in their names, such as cetearyl alcohol, behenyl alcohol, and benzyl alcohol. In my Baby Wipes Rating List, I give Tencel as a plant-based material a rating of 5 out of 10. It is chemically impossible for a salt (sodium benzoate) to react with an acid (citric or any other) to form a hydrocarbon (benzene).. Here is their reply for anyone interested in those baby wipes: Regarding concerns about benzene formation related to sodium or potassium benzoate, our supplier certifies that this ingredient does not contain any Benzene nor does it contain any Benzene during the production process.